SHARE
COPY LINK

CRIME

Germany makes upskirting illegal and promises harsh penalties

Upskirting, the act of secretly photographing under a person's clothes without consent, will be a criminal offence in Germany. Those who are caught will face a fine or up to two years in prison.

Germany makes upskirting illegal and promises harsh penalties
Women in Berlin enjoying the warm weather recently. Photo: DPA

The Bundestag passed a law early on Friday that means taking illicit photographs of someone under a person's clothes, such as under their skirt or of their neckline, will become illegal in Germany.

If anyone is caught doing this they can be hit with a fine or a prison sentence of up to two years. It is expected that the law will come into force this autumn.

“To photograph under a woman's skirt or her cleavage area is a shameless violation of her privacy,” said Federal Justice Minister Christine Lambrecht of the centre-left Social Democrats (SPD).

Lambrecht, who pushed through the new law, said this behaviour is unacceptable.

The new legislation will also criminalise photographing victims of accidents or pictures that “display a dead person in a grossly offensive way,” said Lambrecht.

READ ALSO: Germany approves bill to ban upskirting

'Important step'

The change in law has been fuelled by campaigners Ida Marie Sassenberg and Hanna Seidel from the southern German city of Ludwigsburg who launched an online petition last year to ban upskiriting in Germany. It has gathered more than 109,000 signatures.

Seidel welcomed the new law. “It is a great symbol of justice, politics and society,” the 29-year-old said. “Its symbolic value should not be underestimated.”

Following the petition, the states of Baden-Württemberg, Bavaria, North Rhine-Westphalia and Saarland took up the issue and started legislative initiatives in the Bundesrat.

Seidel said that the federal law does not completely solve the problem. “A lot still needs to happen in society. But it's a right and very important step,” she said.

Nils Pickert from the feminist organisation Pinkstinks said that upskirting often takes place in large crowds, such as on buses and trains, at festivals or in clubs and bars.

“There are people who put cameras in public toilets to film women,” Pickert said. The photos are often for personal use, but can be shared with friends or on the Internet.

Pickert said this kind of sexualised violence “must be taken seriously as an issue and this must be reflected in the punishment”.

Tightening criminal law

Johannes Fechner, the SPD's legal policy spokesman in the Bundestag, said victims of these attacks often do not realise they have been photographed.

Up until now upskirting has only been punished in Germany as an administrative offence with small fines, which has not deterred offenders. “Therefore we are closing an important gap in punishing here, and tightening the criminal law at this point,” said Fechner.

Jan-Marco Luczak, legal policy spokesman for the centre-right CDU/CSU parliamentary group, said secret photography is unfortunately becoming more widespread as everyone carries phones with cameras. “As legislators, we are taking decisive action against it,” he said.

The assaults are humiliating and hurtful to victims and often have far-reaching psychological consequences, Luczak added.

The act of upskirting is criminalised already in some countries across the world, including Scotland, India, New Zealand and Finland. It also became a criminal offence in England and Wales in 2019 after a campaign.

As well as the law on taking illicit photographs, the Bundestag also passed a ban on tobacco advertising as well as a voucher scheme for package holidaymakers.

If a trip cannot be taken due to coronavirus, tour operators will in future be able to offer their customers vouchers. Customers can opt for a refund of the money paid, or for the voucher.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

MILITARY

What we know so far about the alleged spies accused of plotting attacks in Germany for Russia

Investigators have arrested two German-Russian men on suspicion of spying for Russia and planning attacks in Germany – including on US army targets – to undermine military support for Ukraine, prosecutors have said.

What we know so far about the alleged spies accused of plotting attacks in Germany for Russia

The pair, identified only as Dieter S. and Alexander J., were arrested in Bayreuth in the southeastern state of Bavaria on Wednesday, federal prosecutors said in a statement.

The main accused, Dieter S., is alleged to have scouted potential targets for attacks, “including facilities of the US armed forces” stationed in Germany.

Russia’s ambassador to Berlin was summoned by the foreign ministry following the arrests.

Germany would not “allow Putin to bring his terror to Germany”, Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock subsequently said on X.

But Russian officials rejected the accusations.

“No evidence was presented to prove the detainees’ plans or their possible connection to representatives of Russian structures,” the Russian embassy in Berlin said in a post on X.

Police have searched both men’s homes and places of work.

They are suspected of “having been active for a foreign intelligence service” in what prosecutors described as a “particularly serious case” of espionage.

Interior Minister Nancy Faeser likewise called the allegations “a particularly serious case of suspected agent activity for (Vladimir) Putin’s criminal regime”.

“We will continue to thwart such threat plans,” she said, reiterating Germany’s steadfast support for Ukraine.

How US army facilities were targeted 

“We can never accept that espionage activities in Germany take place,” Chancellor Olaf Scholz said at a meeting of EU leaders in Brussels.

According to prosecutors, Dieter S. had been exchanging information with a person linked to Russian intelligence services since October 2023, discussing possible acts of sabotage.

“The actions were intended, in particular, to undermine the military support provided from Germany to Ukraine against the Russian aggression,” prosecutors said.

The accused allegedly expressed readiness to “commit explosive and arson attacks mainly on military infrastructure and industrial sites in Germany”.

Dieter S. collected information about potential targets, “including facilities of the US armed forces”.

Fellow accused Alexander J. began assisting him from March 2024, they added.

Dieter S. scouted potential targets by taking photos and videos of military transport and equipment. He then allegedly shared the information with his contact person.

Der Spiegel magazine reported that the military facilities spied on included the US army base in Grafenwoehr in Bavaria.

“Among other things, there is an important military training area there where the US army trains Ukrainian soldiers, for example on Abrams battle tanks,” Der Spiegel wrote.

Dieter S. faces an additional charge of belonging to a “foreign terrorist organisation”. Prosecutors said they suspect he was a fighter in an armed unit of eastern Ukraine’s self-proclaimed pro-Russian “People’s Republic of Donetsk” in 2014-2016.

Espionage showdown 

Germany is Ukraine’s second-largest supplier of military aid, and news of the spy arrests came as Vice Chancellor Robert Habeck was on a visit to Kyiv.

“We will continue to provide Ukraine with massive support and will not allow ourselves to be intimidated,” Interior Minister Faeser said.

Germany has been shaken by several cases of alleged spying for Russia since the invasion of Ukraine in 2022, amid suggestions that some German officials have been too sympathetic with Moscow in the past.

A former German intelligence officer is on trial in Berlin, accused of handing information to Moscow that showed Germany had access to details of Russian mercenary operations in Ukraine. He denies the charges.

In November 2022, a German man was handed a suspended sentence for passing information to Russian intelligence while serving as a German army reserve officer.

“We know that the Russian power apparatus is also focusing on our country — we must respond to this threat with resistance and determination,” Justice Minister Marco Buschmann said Thursday.

READ ALSO: Two Germans charged with treason in Russia spying case

Additionally, a man suspected of aiding a plot by Russian intelligence services to assassinate Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has been arrested in Poland, on Thursday, according to Polish and Ukrainian prosecutors.

It said the suspect had stated he was “ready to act on behalf of the military intelligence services of the Russian Federation and established contact with Russian citizens directly involved in the war in Ukraine”.

Russian authorities for their part have levelled treason charges against dozens of people accused of aiding Kyiv and the West since the invasion.

A Russian court sentenced a resident of Siberia’s Omsk region to 12 years in jail earlier this month for trying to pass secrets to the German government in exchange for help moving there.

SHOW COMMENTS