SHARE
COPY LINK

HEALTH

Bundestag votes against ‘opt-out’ system of organ donation in Germany

The Bundestag has voted against a proposal for a new 'presumed consent' organ donation system.

Bundestag votes against 'opt-out' system of organ donation in Germany
An organ donor card. Photo: DPA

It means the country’s organ donation laws, which require people to ‘opt-in’ to express explicit consent, will stay in place.

On Thursday, following an emotional debate, the Bundestag rejected plans from a group of MPs led by Health Minister Jens Spahn, of the Christian Democrats, and Social Democrats' health expert Karl Lauterbach.

They wanted to change the rules so that citizens in Germany would be asked to state whether they object to having their organs or tissue harvested after they are pronounced brain dead.

Those who say “no” would be listed in a national registry run by the Health Ministry, while all others would be considered potential donors – a principle in place across most of the EU.

In a roll-call vote, 379 MPs voted against the proposal, 292 supported it and three abstained.

Instead, there was a majority in favour of extending the current system but urging more people to opt-in.

The parliament backed the motion by a group led by Green Party leader Annalena Baerbock, Left Party leader Katja Kipping and Bundestag Vice-President Wolfgang Kubicki of the Free Democrats.

A total of 432 MPs voted in favour, 200 against and 37 abstained. In principle, the current regulation remains in force: organs and tissue may only be removed after death if the person concerned has given his or her consent during his or her lifetime, has an organ donor card or the relatives have agreed to the removal.

However, in a bid to shorten Germany's transplant waiting lists, people will be asked in future if they'd like to donate organs at least every 10 years, when renewing their national identity card.

They will also be able to register to donate with a new online register.

READ ALSO: Germany debates changing to 'opt-out' organ donation system

9,000 people waiting

Waiting lists for organs in Germany are getting longer, but the willingness to donate is declining.

According to figures from the German Foundation for Organ Donation, there were more than 1,300 donors in 2007 but in 2017 there were less than 900. A total of 932 people donated an organ last year.

More than 9,000 seriously ill people are currently on the organ waiting list in Germany. About 7,500 are waiting for a kidney. The rest hope for a heart, lung, liver or pancreas.

With 11.5 donors per million people, Germany's organ donation rate is fairly low compared to other countries. In Spain that number is 48, while it's 30.8 in the US.

Those who supported the 'opt-out' system said it would save lives.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

HEALTH

Danish parties agree to raise abortion limit to 18 weeks

Denmark's government has struck a deal with four other parties to raise the point in a pregnancy from which a foetus can be aborted from 12 weeks to 18 weeks, in the first big change to Danish abortion law in 50 years.

Danish parties agree to raise abortion limit to 18 weeks

The government struck the deal with the Socialist Left Party, the Red Green Alliance, the Social Liberal Party and the Alternative party, last week with the formal announcement made on Monday  

“In terms of health, there is no evidence for the current week limit, nor is there anything to suggest that there will be significantly more or later abortions by moving the week limit,” Sophie Løhde, Denmark’s Minister of the Interior and Health, said in a press release announcing the deal.

The move follows the recommendations of Denmark’s Ethics Council, which in September 2023 proposed raising the term limit, pointing out that Denmark had one of the most restrictive abortion laws in Western Europe. 

READ ALSO: 

Under the deal, the seven parties, together with the Liberal Alliance and the Conservatives, have also entered into an agreement to replace the five regional abortion bodies with a new national abortion board, which will be based in Aarhus. 

From July 1st, 2025, this new board will be able to grant permission for abortions after the 18th week of pregnancy if there are special considerations to take into account. 

The parties have also agreed to grant 15-17-year-olds the right to have an abortion without parental consent or permission from the abortion board.

Marie Bjerre, Denmark’s minister for Digitalization and Equality, said in the press release that this followed logically from the age of sexual consent, which is 15 years old in Denmark. 

“Choosing whether to have an abortion is a difficult situation, and I hope that young women would get the support of their parents. But if there is disagreement, it must ultimately be the young woman’s own decision whether she wants to be a mother,” she said. 

The bill will be tabled in parliament over the coming year with the changes then coming into force on June 1st, 2025.

The right to free abortion was introduced in Denmark in 1973. 

SHOW COMMENTS