SHARE
COPY LINK

SIEMENS

Outrage in Germany as Siemens backs Aussie mine project

Environmental activists across the world have slammed German engineering conglomerate Siemens after it decided to carry on with a controversial coal mine project in Australia.

Outrage in Germany as Siemens backs Aussie mine project
Protesters in Munich on Monday with a sign reading "No more words." Photo: DPA

After holding talks with environmentalists in Berlin last week, CEO Joe Kaeser said Sunday that Siemens would go ahead with plans to provide rail infrastructure for the Carmichael mine in Queensland.

On Monday, activists from the “Fridays for Future” movement responded by protesting in front of the company's offices in 15 German cities, including Berlin, Hamburg and Munich.

In a statement on their website “Fridays for Future” said Siemens' decision was “catastrophic”, and that the mine “threatens worldwide efforts to keep global warming under 1.5 degrees Celsius.”

'Destroy' reputation

Australian climate activist Varsha Yajman, 17, told AFP that the decision would “destroy” Siemens' reputation.

“It is time for Kaeser to realize the consequences of his actions and give us the sustainable future we deserve.”

Siemens, which aims to be carbon neutral by 2030, signed a contract in December to provide rail signalling services for the Carmichael project.

The proposed mine, owned by India's Adani group, has long been controversial, but anger over the multi-billion-euro project has been fanned by Australia's catastrophic bushfire season.

Amid growing calls for Siemens to quit the project, Kaeser met with leading “Fridays for Future” activist Luisa Neubauer in Berlin on Friday and claimed he was “on the same side” as environmentalists.

Neubauer – who turned down an supervisory board role she was offered at Siemens energy subsidiary – spoke of an “inexcusable mistake”.

The 23-year-old climate campaigner tweeted that he decision concerned “is about responsibility of global corporations & about a coal mine that should not exist.”

On Saturday, Sweden's top climate activist Greta Thunberg also urged Kaeser to make what she said was “the only right decision”.

“It seems that Siemens have the power to stop, delay or at least interrupt the building of the huge Adani coal mine,” Thunberg tweeted.

'Historic mistake'

But Kaeser announced on Sunday evening that Siemens would “fulfil their contractual obligations” on the project.

“While I do have a lot of empathy for environmental matters, I do need to balance different interests of different stakeholders,” he said.

The CEO nonetheless pledged to “give environmental concerns more attention in the future” by setting up a sustainability committee.

Neubauer accused Siemens of having made an “historic mistake”.

Toby Thorpe, from School Strike for Climate Australia, called the decision “appalling”.

“Their support not only fuels climate change, but will fuel more natural disasters among the likes of the bushfire crisis in Australia.”

By Monday afternoon, #Siemens and #Siemensfuelsfire were the two most commonly treading topics on Twitter in Germany, with one user stating that Siemens does not just “know about the climate crisis, but chooses to directly support the expansion of coal mining.”

'No room for coal'

The open-cut Carmichael mine is set to become operational next year and produce up to 27 million tonnes of coal annually.

Adani spent years trying to secure private finance for the coal mine before announcing in 2018 it was self-financing a trimmed down, $2-billion version of the  project.

Supporters say the mine will bring hundreds of much-needed jobs to rural Queensland in eastern Australia.

But conservationists say the project threatens local vulnerable species and means coal will have to be shipped from a port near the already-damaged Great Barrier Reef.

Much of the coal from the mine will be burned in India, a country with some of the highest levels of air pollution on Earth.

The United Nations says emissions must decline more than 7.5 percent annually in order to hit the 1.5C temperature goal laid out in the 2015 Paris deal.

Andrew Grant, head analyst at the Carbon Tracker think tank, told AFP that coal was facing an oversupply crisis, with known reserves containing enough fuel for the next 130 years.

“If we are serious about achieving our goals under Paris then there's just no room for new coal,” he said.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

CLIMATE

‘We’ll continue our protests’: Environmental activists confront Siemens bosses in Munich

Siemens chief executive Joe Kaeser faced environmental protests inside and outside the group's annual shareholder meeting on Wednesday.

'We'll continue our protests': Environmental activists confront Siemens bosses in Munich
Demonstrators in Munich on Wednesday. Photo: DPA

Outraged by the group's sticking to a contract to supply rail equipment to a massive Australian coal mining project, demonstrators were rallying outside the Munich Olympiahalle ahead of the 10:00am kickoff.

A group of around 100 were on the scene from early in the morning, some forming a human chain.

Late Tuesday, Greenpeace had draped a banner from the company's headquarters reading “Bush fires start here”.

“We will continue our protests for as long as Siemens doesn't back down,” said Helena Marschall, a representative of the movement, at a Tuesday press conference.

Marschall herself is slated to speak inside the venue later Wednesday, while the demonstrators plan to urge the company to “abandon coal” at a larger protest in the afternoon.

Kaeser kept activists and observers on tenterhooks for weeks as he decided whether to uphold a contract with India's Adani group related to its Carmichael mine project in Australia.

In the end, he stuck to Siemens' agreement to supply the rail signalling equipment for the massive open-cast mine, not far from the iconic natural landmark of the Great Barrier Reef.

READ ALSO: Outrage in Germany as Siemens back Aussie mine project

'Fulfil contractual obligations'

Groups like Extinction Rebellion and Fridays for Future have homed in on the shareholder meeting as an opportunity to renew the pressure on Siemens.

“What's more important: a small financial loss in the short term, or the disastrous consequences such a project will have for generations?” Marschall said.

She and other environmentalists have been invited to speak inside the cordon by a group of Siemens shareholders.

In mid-January, CEO Kaeser met leading German Fridays for Future activist Luisa Neubauer after protests across the country against Siemens.

But he later said in a statement: “We must fulfil our contractual obligations” relating to the 18-million-euro ($22 million) deal.

Protesters at the meeting. Photo: DPA

“Only being a credible partner whose word counts also ensures that we can remain an effective partner for a greener future,” Kaeser insisted.

Nevertheless, the company plans to create a “Sustainability Committee” with powers to block environmentally questionable projects.

Siemens says it backs the 2015 Paris Agreement and aims to become carbon-neutral by 2030.

27 mn tonnes of coal

The open-cut Carmichael mine is set to become operational next year and produce up to 27 million tonnes of coal annually.

Adani spent years trying to secure private finance for the coal mine before announcing in 2018 it was self-financing a trimmed-down, $2 billion version of the  project.

Supporters say the mine will bring hundreds of much-needed jobs to rural Queensland in eastern Australia.

But conservationists say the project threatens local vulnerable species and notes that the coal will have to be shipped from a port near the already damaged Great Barrier Reef.

Much of the coal from the mine will be burned in India, a country with some of the world's highest levels of air pollution.

By Ralf Isermann with Tom Barfield in Frankfurt

SHOW COMMENTS