SHARE
COPY LINK

VISAS

Explained: How Danish visa laws may have been misused to exploit Chinese chefs

Danish working visa laws are being misused to exploit Chinese workers in Denmark’s restaurant industry, according to recent reports.

Explained: How Danish visa laws may have been misused to exploit Chinese chefs
File photo: Thomas Lekfeldt/Ritzau Scanpix

A work visa law for non-EU nationals working in Denmark, known as the pay limit scheme (beløbsordningen in Danish), has come into particular focus in reports by broadcaster DR and trade union media Fagbladet 3F.

The reports have uncovered evidence of Chinese nationals working for well under the minimum wage, for excessive hours and living in sub-standard accommodation.

The beløbsordningen provision enables companies to hire employees who are nationals of non-EU countries, provided they are paid a minimum of 417,793 kroner per year (roughly 35,500 kroner per month).

The wages must be paid into a Danish bank account, and employment conditions must comply with Danish labour standards.

It is this system which is used to apply for working residency permits for Chinese chefs, but they do not receive pay stipulated by the scheme, according to the reports.

“We are receiving an increasingly high number of (work permit) applications for Chinese chefs and are still seeing examples of rules being circumvented, and as such we will begin to strengthen our application assessments,” Frederik Gammeltoft, head of department at the Agency for International Recruitment and Integration (Styrelsen for International Rekruttering og Integration, SIRI) told DR.

Figures published by the broadcaster show that 588 and 582 Chinese nationals were registered to work in the hotel and restaurant industry in 2017 and 2018 respectively. That represents a huge increase in comparison with the 22 who were registered in 2010.

The authority has now described to DR routes by which the pay limit scheme may have been abused.

Digital login and bank account not administered by work permit holder

Chinese chefs granted permits to work in Denmark may not be in control of NemID, the country’s secure digital login system which allows access to public services such as tax registration, as well as private bank accounts.

“It may be the case that the individual in question is not in control of their own bank account and thereby cannot access their own salary,” Gammeltoft said to DR.

Wages paid back to employer

In some cases, money may have been moved in and out of Danish bank accounts registered to the Chinese nationals, meaning the terms of the pay limit scheme are technically met.

“We have seen examples of the chef being required to pay parts of their wages back to the employer,” Gammeltoft said.

Two workers paid one salary

Another method to circumvent the rules might be to hire a married couple, but only provide a visa and thereby wages for one.

“We have seen examples of chefs that have been given residency permits not receiving the wages they were promised. There may have been instances of the individual being allowed to bring their spouse with them (to Denmark) and they then work two-for-one, so to speak,” Gammeltoft told DR.

READ ALSO: Is the Danish work visa law to blame for Chinese chef living in Copenhagen restaurant's storage room?

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

VISAS

Which European countries offer a ‘digital nomad’ visa?

With the world of work rapidly changing, digital nomad visas are now in high demand as a way to experience life in another country while continuing to work remotely. Here are the European countries that you can obtain one for, and what’s involved.

Which European countries offer a 'digital nomad' visa?

Many countries have introduced digital nomad visas as a means to attract visitors and boost their economy. 

Generally, to obtain one, those applying need to be able to conduct their work online, to have a contract with a company based outside the country they’re applying to, and to meet a monthly salary level. 

Additionally, applicants will need to prove that they have a minimum level of health insurance, means to support themselves and accommodation organised. 

It’s also important to note that if you are a citizen of an EEA/Schengen country, you may not be able to apply for these visas – you already have the right to live and work in these countries. 

Germany, Austria, Sweden and Switzerland do not currently have offer a ‘digital nomad visa, although there are alternatives. 

France and Denmark also have options for those wanting to work remotely. 

Several European countries, however, now do offer these visas. 

Albania

Albania’s new Unique Permit scheme allows digital nomads to apply for a Type D visa, which is valid for a year, and which can be renewed for up to five years. 

While there are no explicit requirements for a monthly or yearly salary, it has been suggested that a minimum yearly income of €9.024,33 would result in an approval. 

Applications can take up to twelve weeks, and the costs for the visa will vary, based on your country of origin. 

Croatia

Croatia introduced their Digital Nomad Residence Permit in 2021, and it is becoming a popular option for remote workers. 

This visa is valid for a year, and can be renewed – although you’ll have to leave the country for six months before you can reapply. 

A minimum monthly salary of €2.446,69 is required for a successful application. 

The cost of this visa will vary, depending on the country from which you apply. 

Cyprus

Cyprus has an appealing Digital Nomad Visa program, albeit one that is capped – only 500 are available per year. 

Applicants will need to be able to prove a minimum monthly income of €3,500 to receive a visa, and it is valid for one year – renewable for a further two. 

Applicants will need to pay €140 – €70 for the application fee, and €70 for the Alien Registration Certificate. 

Estonia

A trailblazer in attracting remote workers, Estonia’s Digital Nomad Visa is one of Europe’s most desirable. 

This is due to the country’s excellent online infrastructure and support for remote workers, through its E-Residency Card program. 

Applicants can also expect a response to their application within a month – a much shorter waiting period than for several other countries. 

Applicants must pay a €60 application fee, and be able to show evidence of a €4,500 monthly salary. 

Greece

Greece’s Digital Nomad Visa is valid for two years, renewable for another two years.

It costs €75, and you’ll need to be making at least €3,500 a month to be successful when applying. 

Hungary

Hungary’s ‘White Card’ was introduced in 2021 to attract remote workers to the central European country. 

The ‘White Card’ is valid for one year, and can be extended once for a further year. 

Applicants need to be able to show that they’re earning the equivalent of €3,000 a month, and costs €110 to apply for. 

Iceland

Iceland also has a digital nomad visa, although it’s slightly different to many others. 

The country’s Long-term visa for Remote Work is only valid for up to 180 days, although it can be applied for again 90 days after leaving the Schengen zone.

It costs €80.96 to apply, and you will need to be making at least €6.636,13 a month to be successful. 

Italy

Italy’s digital nomad visa is Europe’s newest, effective from April 4th. The initial visa is valid for a year, and there is no upper limit on renewals, as long as the applicant still meets the criteria.

It’s important to know that applicants will need to be earning €28,000 a year to be successful. The visa must be applied for at the nearest consulate, and costs €116.

Malta

Malta’s Nomad Residence Permit is valid for one year and can be renewed a further three times, for a maximum stay of four years. 

Applicants need to show that they are making at least €42,000 a year and the application fee is €300.

Norway

Norway’s digital nomad visa offering is rather unique. 

First, the Digital Nomad Visa is valid for up to two years, and can be reapplied for. Applicants must show an annual income of €35,719 and the application costs €600. 

Then there’s the Svalbard Digital Nomad Visa. While it has much the same requirements as the regular digital nomad visa, successful applicants must also reside within the Svalbard archipelago, within the Arctic Circle. 

Amazingly, there is no expiry date for the Svalbard visa  – it has a lifetime duration. However, you will have to pay Norwegian taxes. 

Both of these visas can be applied for through the official Norwegian government website.

Spain

Although it was only introduced last year, Spain’s Digital Nomad Visa programme has already proved successful. 

The initial visa is valid for one year, and it can be renewed for up to five years. 

It costs €80 to apply, and applicants need to show that they’re making a minimum of €2,646 a month

Portugal

Portugal’s digital nomad visa program is one of Europe’s most well-known.

Two specific visas specifically cater towards digital nomads. The Temporary Stay Visa is valid for three months and can be renewed up to four times – the maximum stay being a year. 

This visa costs €75 to apply for, and applicants have to show a monthly salary of €3,280.

The Residency Visa is valid for four months, after which it can be reapplied for, lasting two years. 

It costs €80 to apply for, and the income threshold is increased to €3,304. 

Family members can accompany those on a Residency Visa, while on a Temporary Stay visa, they cannot.

SHOW COMMENTS