Chile archbishop remains silent over abuse cover-up claims

Santiago Archbishop Ricardo Ezzati on Wednesday went before a prosecutor investigating a sex abuse scandal that has roiled the Catholic Church in Chile but declined to answer questions about accusations he was involved in a cover-up.

Chile archbishop remains silent over abuse cover-up claims
Ricardo Ezzati waves as he leaves after declaring at the public prosecutor's office for alleged cover-up of sex abuse in Rancagua, Chile on October 3, 2018. Photo: Claudio Reyes/AFP

The Catholic Church is under increasing scrutiny because of the escalating worldwide sex abuse crisis, which has seen scandals emerge in North and South America, Europe and Australia that have involved widespread claims of abuse – and cover-ups.

The highest-ranking member of the church in Chile, Ezzati entered the prosecutor's offices in the southern town of Rancagua under heavy police guard and surrounded by media.

A solitary protester brandished a sign that read: “Depraved Roman Church.”

After an hour being interviewed by Emilio Arias – the prosecutor investigating decades of sexual abuse of minors by Chilean priests – 76-year-old Ezzati left the courthouse saying: “We are all going to collaborate with everything.” 

READ ALSO: Pope admits 'grave mistakes' in handling of Chile sex abuse scandal

No answers

Hugo Rivera, his lawyer, said the cardinal had used his right not to answer questions about accusations he covered up the sexual abuse of minors, in particular crimes committed by a top diocesan aide.

“For now the cardinal has not spoken until we speak with the public prosecutor's office about the definitive dismissal” of the charges, the lawyer said.

He insisted the cardinal “is innocent.”

Arias began investigating scores of abuse cases in July after outrage over the church's own probe into decades of abuse by priests – crimes for which it often failed to take any action or handed down lenient punishments.

Pope Francis, who has removed several Chilean bishops over the scandal, admitted there was a “culture of abuse” within the Chilean church after sending investigators from the Vatican. 

The pontiff said after meeting abuse victims that the church had failed “to listen and react” to the allegations, and vowed to “restore justice.”

Arias' office said in August that it was investigating 119 cases of abuse against Chile's clergy going back to 1960.

“We are going to prosecute anyone who has committed crimes,” Arias told reporters after questioning Ezzati.

“There is no witch hunt,” he said. “If there is a crime, we will prosecute… we will accuse and go to trial,” he said.

Ezzati has denied allegations that he covered up cases of abuse, including those of a top aide, Oscar Munoz. Munoz, 56, is under house arrest while a probe continues into allegations he raped at least seven children.

Abuse victim Juan Carlos Cruz mocked Ezzati's stance on Twitter.

READ ALSO: Pope accepts resignations of two more Chilean bishops: Vatican

Coward Ezzati'

“The coward Ezzati goes to testify as an accused and decides not to speak so as not to incriminate himself,” said Cruz, one of the victims of the most notorious pedophile priest, Fernando Karadima.

Karadima, once a revered Chilean cleric, was formally expelled from the church by Pope Francis last Friday. 

Francis caused an uproar during a visit to Chile in January when he went out of his way to defend controversial bishop Juan Barros, a protege of Karadima's who was accused of covering up his crimes. 

Francis had appointed Barros as bishop in 2015 when the allegations against him were common knowledge in Chile.

Francis subsequently apologized, and accepted Barros' resignation in June.

Ezzati is now in the eye of the storm. In September, he was forced to sit out the traditional showpiece mass in Santiago Cathedral to celebrate Chile's Independence Day.

And this week, Chile's church was criticized by victims' groups for publishing a manual on its website – meant to provide guidelines for priests for interacting with children – which instructed them not to “touch the genitals” or “sleep with” children, give massage – or kiss children, adolescents or vulnerable people “on the mouth.”

The instructions were signed by Ezzati. Victims' groups said it was outrageous that priests had to be instructed that touching a child's genitals was wrong.

Ezzati later removed the manual from the website.

Chile's conservative President Sebastian Pinera is due to have talks with the pope during a visit to the Vatican on October 13.



Pope appoints French woman to senior synod post

Pope Francis has broken with Catholic tradition to appoint a woman as an undersecretary of the synod of bishops, the first to hold the post with voting rights in a body that studies major questions of doctrine.

Pope appoints French woman to senior synod post
Pope Francis has appointed Nathalie Becquart as undersecretary of the synod of bishops. She is the first woman to hold the post. Photo: AFP

Frenchwoman Nathalie Becquart is one of the two new undersecretaries named on Saturday to the synod, where she has been a consultant since 2019.

The appointment signals the pontiff's desire “for a greater participation of women in the process of discernment and decision-making in the church”, said Cardinal Mario Grech, the secretary-general of the synod.

“During the previous synods, the number of women participating as experts and listeners has increased,” he said.

“With the nomination of Sister Nathalie Becquart and her possibility of participating in voting, a door has opened.”

The synod is led by bishops and cardinals who have voting rights and also comprises experts who cannot vote, with the next gathering scheduled for autumn 2022.

A special synod on the Amazon in 2019 saw 35 female “auditors” invited to the assembly, but none could vote.

The Argentinian-born pope has signalled his wish to reform the synod and have women and laypeople play a greater role in the church.

He named Spaniard Luis Marin de San Martin as the other under undersecretary in the synod of bishops.

Becquart, 52, a member of the France-based Xaviere Sisters, has a master's degree in management from the prestigious HEC business school in Paris and studied in Boston before joining the order.