Are North African countries ‘safe’ for deportees from Germany?

German conservatives want to add three North African countries to the government’s list of “safe countries of origin” in a bid to speed up processing and deportations of asylum-seekers. But critics say these countries aren’t safe for certain groups, including journalists and homosexuals. The Local took a closer look at the debate.

Are North African countries 'safe' for deportees from Germany?
A German detension centre which holds deportees. Photo: DPA

The North African nations of Morocco, Tunisia and Algeria along with the former Soviet republic of Georgia should be safe countries of origin, the German government proposed last week.

The bill is the initiative of German Interior Minister Horst Seehofer, part of his “Migration Masterplan.”

So-called “safe countries of origin” currently include all EU members, six Balkans nations, Ghana and Senegal.

Seehofer argues adding four new countries to the safe list would lead to speedier decisions – and deportations – for asylum applicants from those nations, the majority of whom have no right to asylum in Germany.

He also hopes to signal to people currently living in North Africa and Georgia that it would be pointless to travel to Germany to seek asylum.

Germany received 8700 asylum applications from those four countries in 2017, according to DPA, though the total number of arrivals could be higher.

This is the second time the German government has tried to extend the list of safe countries to include North African states, otherwise known as the Maghreb countries.

Why were previous proposals blocked from passage?

Last year a similar proposal was blocked from passing through the Bundesrat, the German upper house of parliament, by the Green party.

The party – long proponents of a humanitarian approach to asylum policy – disagrees that the countries in question are entirely “safe,” not least because in the Maghreb countries homosexuality is punishable by law.

“It’s still the case that in the Maghreb states journalists, minorities and homosexuals aren’t safe from persecution and internment,” said Green party head Robert Habeck, pointing to reports of torture and unfair legal proceedings. “That’s why I don’t see these states as safe.”   

The Green party are in power in nine out of Germany’s 16 states. If all of those states vote against or abstain from the vote in the upper house, the bill can’t pass. Some of those states have already indicated they would abstain, others that they would decide nearer to the vote.

The Green’s Winfried Kretschmann, Baden-Württemberg’s centre right leaning Minister President, has come under fire from his own party for indicating his state will support the bill.

Why are politicians supporting the bill?

Proponents of the bill, including many of Seehofer’s colleagues from the Bavarian Christian Socialists (CSU), argue that none of the four states are at war or engage in systematic torture of their citizens.

That means that very few asylum-seekers from these countries are currently given refugee status: 4.3 percent of applicants from Algeria, 4.4 percent from Morocco, 2.1 percent from Georgia, and just 0.7 percent from Tunisia, according to DPA.

But at the moment, deporting failed asylum seekers back to these countries can still be difficult, especially if there’s a risk, however small, of the deportee facing torture or the death penalty.

In some cases, as in the botched deportation of Sami A., Osama bin Laden’s alleged former bodyguard, to Tunisia last week, German courts think that risk is too big.

SEE ALSO: Scandal grows over 'unlawful' deportation of alleged bin Laden body guard

Appealing his deportation order, Sami A. successfully argued that he was under threat of torture if he were to be returned to Tunisia. That should have prevented him being sent back, but somehow he was put on a plane anyway. Germany's federal office for refugees and migration says the did not receive the message from an administrative court – in which A. had made an appeal – in time to halt A.'s deportation.

Critics of the proposal worry Tunisia and the others being included on the list of “safe countries” may influence similar court decisions in the future and prevent each case being decided on its own merits.

Less controversial is the addition of the former Soviet republic of Georgia to the list. Human rights have been steadily improving in the country and the EU recently dropped visa requirements for Georgians.


Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


Dexit: One in 10 Germans in favour of leaving the EU

EU approval ratings in Germany have declined, but the vast majority of Germans are still in favour of staying in the EU, according to a new study.

Dexit: One in 10 Germans in favour of leaving the EU
The EU flag flying outside the Reichstag in the German capital Berlin. Photo: DPA

Brexit hasn't quite happened yet, but some residents in Germany say they want to follow in the UK's footsteps and vote to quit the bloc.

A total of 10 percent of Germans are in favour of the country's exit from the EU – so-called 'Dexit' – according to research carried out by the European Parliament, reported the Tagesspiegel.

That's an increase of one percentage point compared to the last survey in autumn.

Germany's exit from the EU has been called for by the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD). The party's draft manifesto states that if the EU is not reshaped in line with the party's ideas “in an appropriate timeframe”, Germany must leave the bloc.

SEE ALSO: Far-right AfD to campaign on German EU exit

But most Germans are strongly in favour of the EU, despite a drop in approval ratings. The 'spring Eurobarometer' found that 76 percent of respondents in Germany considered EU membership “a good thing”. That's five percentage points lower than the last survey.

However, the figure is well above the European average.

The EU Parliament poll, which was carried out ahead of next month’s European elections, states that the majority of the bloc is happy to remain a member.

In an overview of the remaining EU27 countries, excluding Britain, 68 percent of voters would opt to remain in the bloc while only 14 percent would decide to quit.

Meanwhile, a total of 61 percent of respondents consider EU membership to be a “good thing”. This is one percentage point lower than in the autumn, when it reached its highest level in 26 years.

People in the Czech Republic (33 percent) and Italy (36 percent) were the least enthusiastic about the EU.

SEE ALSO: Voting in Germany – What you need to know about the EU elections

'Continued strong support for the EU'

The report's authors said the poll “shows a continued strong support for the European Union”.

They added: “Despite the challenges of the past years – and in cases such as the ongoing debate surrounding Brexit possibly even because of it – the European sense of togetherness does not seem to have weakened.

“One month ahead of the date originally scheduled for the withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the EU as laid down in Article 50, close to seven Europeans in ten said they would vote to remain in the EU if a referendum was held in their country.”

Meanwhile, only 38 percent of respondents said they knew that European elections were being held in May.

The European Parliament's survey was carried out across all 28 member states and interviewed 27,973 Europeans between February 19th to March 4th, 2019.