SHARE
COPY LINK

WAR

‘Fates we will never know’: search for WWII missing drawing to a sombre close

What happened to the 1.3 million Germans who went missing after the Second World War remains a mystery. But some of the loved ones of these missing persons haven't given up hope in finding some answers.

'Fates we will never know': search for WWII missing drawing to a sombre close
Neuengamme concentration camp memorial in Hamburg, where almost 43,000 of the over 100,000 prisoners perished. Photo: DPA
Diethild Heubel pulls a precious document from a binder: a yellowed decades-old letter, neatly handwritten by her father, a German soldier taken prisoner at the end of the Second World War.
 
“This is his last proof of life, the last time he wrote to us,” the 83-year-old said in an interview in her apartment in the Bavarian town of Noerdlingen.

Her father Gerhard Stuerzebecher was a soldier in Adolf Hitler's army, the Wehrmacht. In 1945, he was interned in Austria in a Soviet prison camp.

Heubel was 10 years old at the time, and she and her mother never heard from him again.

“We were refugees — we had lost everything, but the worst part of it all was that we never knew what happened to him,” she sighed, her eyes fixated on a picture of her as a child sitting on her father's lap, a demure smile on her lips.

“I still think of him every day. He was a teacher back home, he did not like war and yet he had to fight in two world wars,” said the now elderly woman.

“To not know how he died and where he is buried… it's hard.”

1.3 million mysteries

Despite the passage of seven decades, many Germans are still searching for loved ones — soldiers and civilians — who vanished at the end of the war.

Their requests land in the office of the tracing service of the German Red Cross in Munich, created at the end of the conflict to determine the fate of some 20 million missing persons.

“At first, the number of cases tracked down was very high, but today there are about 1.3 million fates that we will never know,” said Thomas Huber, 59, the service's current director. 

It relies on German, Soviet and ex-East German archives to try to solve these riddles.

“It is particularly difficult to find dead soldiers in Soviet camps, for example, because their names were badly transcribed or their dates of birth were wrong,” said Christoph Raneberg, who runs the service's archives.

During World War II, some three million Germans were taken prisoner by the Red Army.

The Soviet authorities consistently claimed that around 10 percent of them died in the gulag, while others estimate that far more did not survive the camps.

The last survivors were able to return home in the 1950s, after Stalin's death.

Nearly 75 years after the end of the war, the service's staff still receives around 9,000 requests for information each year, “often from grandchildren who are interested in their family history”, Huber said.

Almost half of the applicants are rewarded with at least some information.

In some cases the results are extraordinary, as when in 2010 two brothers separated in 1945 were reunited after spending the Cold War on different sides of the Berlin Wall.

“Cases involving children who were lost or separated are always spectacular, but for us every case is important,” Huber said. 

Stephan Haidinger, 40, went hunting for traces of his grandfather last year.

“I was diagnosed with cancer and during the treatment, I thought a lot about my ancestors and realized that I did not know my grandfather,” said Haidinger, a shopkeeper in the Bavarian town of Glonn.

'Hope that one day…'

“We only knew that he was captured at the end of the war and interned in a camp but we didn't know why because he wasn't a soldier,” Haidinger said. 

The Red Cross took only four weeks to come up with answers.

“I learned that he had been denounced as a leader of a NSDAP (Nazi party) group and that he died in a concentration camp in 1946,” he said.

“It was shocking but I was relieved to have a response.”

He now knows that his grandfather was buried in a mass grave in northern Germany where he hopes to recover his remains.

It would be “a little like meeting him for the first time”, Haidinger said. 

But as time marches on and the last generation of survivors dies out, the Red Cross tracking service plans to close its doors by 2023.

“We now have all the existing archives — we won't find any new sources of information,” Huber said, promising nevertheless to work at full speed in the 
five remaining years. 

Heubel, for her part, saved all her correspondence with the Red Cross.

She confirms, showing one letter after the other, that her search for her father was in vain.  

However she refuses to give up.

“I cannot move on. Until I die, I will continue to look for him. I hope that one day someone will read his name and tell me, 'I knew him, this is what happened to him'.”

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

TODAY IN FRANCE

France to compensate relatives of Algerian Harki fighters

France has paved the way towards paying reparations to more relatives of Algerians who sided with France in their country's independence war but were then interned in French camps.

France to compensate relatives of Algerian Harki fighters

More than 200,000 Algerians fought with the French army in the war that pitted Algerian independence fighters against their French colonial masters from 1954 to 1962.

At the end of the war, the French government left the loyalist fighters known as Harkis to fend for themselves, despite earlier promises it would look after them.

Trapped in Algeria, many were massacred as the new authorities took revenge.

Thousands of others who fled to France were held in camps, often with their families, in deplorable conditions that an AFP investigation recently found led to the deaths of dozens of children, most of them babies.

READ ALSO Who are the Harkis and why are they still a sore subject in France?

French President Emmanuel Macron in 2021 asked for “forgiveness” on behalf of his country for abandoning the Harkis and their families after independence.

The following year, a law was passed to recognise the state’s responsibility for the “indignity of the hosting and living conditions on its territory”, which caused “exclusion, suffering and lasting trauma”, and recognised the right to reparations for those who had lived in 89 of the internment camps.

But following a new report, 45 new sites – including military camps, slums and shacks – were added on Monday to that list of places the Harkis and their relatives were forced to live, the government said.

Now “up to 14,000 (more) people could receive compensation after transiting through one of these structures,” it said, signalling possible reparations for both the Harkis and their descendants.

Secretary of state Patricia Miralles said the decision hoped to “make amends for a new injustice, including in regions where until now the prejudices suffered by the Harkis living there were not recognised”.

Macron has spoken out on a number of France’s unresolved colonial legacies, including nuclear testing in Polynesia, its role in the Rwandan genocide and war crimes in Algeria.

SHOW COMMENTS