SHARE
COPY LINK

POLITICS

‘No one in Germany would go hungry if food banks didn’t exist’

The outspoken Christian Democrat politician Jens Spahn told a newspaper on Saturday that Germany was a country without poverty thanks to its "Hartz IV" social security payments. Critics called his comments “cold-hearted and aloof.”

‘No one in Germany would go hungry if food banks didn’t exist’
People queuing at a food bank. Photo: DPA

Spahn, who is set to take over as Health Minister in Angela Merkel’s new cabinet, told the Funke Media Group that Hartz IV “provides everyone with what they need to live.”

The social security payments “do not mean poverty exists, they are actually the response of our society against poverty. This welfare is a form of battling poverty,” Spahn said.

Harty IV is a welfare payment received by the long-term unemployed and low earners and is currently set at €416 per month. An average of over 4.3 million people were receiving Hartz IV payments at any one time in 2017.

Spahn also argued that people who live on Hartz IV do not need to receive food from Tafeln (food banks), saying that “no one would go hungry if the Tafeln didn’t exist.”

The real reason behind the establishment of food banks was to ensure “that food isn’t thrown away,” Spahn argued.

The controversial 37-year-old, who is one of Merkel’s loudest critics within her own party, was immediately accused of ignorance by left-wing politicians.

“Hartz IV forces parents to feed their children on €2.70 a day,” Sahra Wagenknecht, leader of Die Linke, said on Monday. “If well-earning politicians like Mr Spahn thinks that’s not poverty, they should spend some time talking to a mother who has to raise her children in those circumstances.”

Wagenknecht’s party colleague Jan Korte said that Spahn's comments made him unfit to serve as German Health Minister.

“Whoever talks about the poor and weak of our society in this cold-hearted and aloof way should not take up the role of a government minister,” he said.

There is dispute in Germany over whether poverty is on the rise or not.

Welfare associations claim that close to 13 million Germans are affected by poverty, a number which has been steadily rising. The figure is based on the proportion of people who earn less than 60 percent of the median household income.

Some academics question the accuracy of this methodology. Walter Krämer, a statistics professor at the Technical University in Dortmund, said last year that “the welfare associations know exactly why they don't want to use serious statistics – because they would show that poverty has been sinking for years.”

This is not the first time that Spahn’s opinionated comments have gotten him in hot water. Last year he complained that too much English was being spoken in Berlin. He claimed that it was unfair that poor immigrants should be expected to learn German while wealthier ones speak English without attempting to master the native language.

The comments, made in the build up to last year's election, were interpreted by critics as a form of populist politics.

2024 EUROPEAN ELECTIONS

From Swexit to Frexit: How Europe’s far-right parties have ditched plans to leave EU

Far-right parties, set to make soaring gains in the European Parliament elections in June, have one by one abandoned plans to get their countries to leave the European Union.

From Swexit to Frexit: How Europe's far-right parties have ditched plans to leave EU

Whereas plans to leave the bloc took centre stage at the last European polls in 2019, far-right parties have shifted their focus to issues such as immigration as they seek mainstream votes.

“Quickly a lot of far-right parties abandoned their firing positions and their radical discourse aimed at leaving the European Union, even if these parties remain eurosceptic,” Thierry Chopin, a visiting professor at the College of Europe in Bruges told AFP.

Britain, which formally left the EU in early 2020 following the 2016 Brexit referendum, remains the only country to have left so far.

Here is a snapshot:

No Nexit 

The Dutch Freedom Party (PVV) led by Geert Wilders won a stunning victory in Dutch national elections last November and polls indicate it will likely top the European vote in the Netherlands.

While the manifesto for the November election stated clearly: “the PVV wants a binding referendum on Nexit” – the Netherlands leaving the EU – such a pledge is absent from the European manifesto.

For more coverage of the 2024 European Elections click here.

The European manifesto is still fiercely eurosceptic, stressing: “No European superstate for us… we will work hard to change the Union from within.”

The PVV, which failed to win a single seat in 2019 European Parliament elections, called for an end to the “expansion of unelected eurocrats in Brussels” and took aim at a “veritable tsunami” of EU environmental regulations.

No Frexit either

Leaders of France’s National Rally (RN) which is also leading the polls in a challenge to President Emmanuel Macron, have also explicitly dismissed talk they could ape Britain’s departure when unveiling the party manifesto in March.

“Our Macronist opponents accuse us… of being in favour of a Frexit, of wanting to take power so as to leave the EU,” party leader Jordan Bardella said.

But citing EU nations where the RN’s ideological stablemates are scoring political wins or in power, he added: “You don’t leave the table when you’re about to win the game.”

READ ALSO: What’s at stake in the 2024 European parliament elections?

Bardella, 28, who took over the party leadership from Marine Le Pen in 2021, is one of France’s most popular politicians.

The June poll is seen as a key milestone ahead of France’s next presidential election in 2027, when Le Pen, who lead’s RN’s MPs, is expected to mount a fourth bid for the top job.

Dexit, maybe later

The co-leader of the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party, Alice Weidel, said in January 2024 that the United Kingdom’s Brexit referendum was an example to follow for the EU’s most populous country.

Weidel said the party, currently Germany’s second most popular, wanted to reform EU institutions to curb the power of the European Commission and address what she saw as a democratic deficit.

But if the changes sought by the AfD could not be realised, “we could have a referendum on ‘Dexit’ – a German exit from the EU”, she said.

The AfD which has recently seen a significant drop in support as it contends with various controversies, had previously downgraded a “Dexit” scenario to a “last resort”.

READ ALSO: ‘Wake-up call’: Far-right parties set to make huge gains in 2024 EU elections

Fixit, Swexit, Polexit…

Elsewhere the eurosceptic Finns Party, which appeals overwhelmingly to male voters, sees “Fixit” as a long-term goal.

The Sweden Democrats (SD) leader Jimmie Åkesson and leading MEP Charlie Weimers said in February in a press op ed that “Sweden is prepared to leave as a last resort”.

Once in favour of a “Swexit”, the party, which props up the government of Prime Minister Ulf Kristersson, in 2019 abandoned the idea of leaving the EU due to a lack of public support.

In November 2023 thousands of far-right supporters in the Polish capital Warsaw called for a “Polexit”.

SHOW COMMENTS