SHARE
COPY LINK

TERRORISM

‘Without Schengen we would be less protected from terror’

Justice minister Simonetta Sommaruga has said Switzerland’s membership of Schengen is vital in the fight against international terrorism and that those who seek to end the Schengen agreement are “irresponsible”.

‘Without Schengen we would be less protected from terror’
Photo: Thierry Charlier/AFP
Sommaruga was speaking in an interview with Blick following the terror attack outside the Houses of Parliament in London on Wednesday.
 
Five people including the attacker were killed when a British man mowed down pedestrians on Westminster bridge before stabbing a police officer outside the Houses of Parliament.
 
Though Switzerland is not in the European Union, since 2008 it has been a member of the Schengen zone, which allows people to move freely between its 26 member countries without a passport. 
 
Schengen has come under fire since the beginning of the migrant crisis, with critics saying it has opened the door to waves of migrants and also allows terrorists and other criminals to move too easily around the zone.
 
However Sommaruga told Blick the “key benefit” of Schengen is police cooperation, allowing national police services to easily and quickly check if a suspect is on the radar of authorities in another Schengen country. 
 
“Without Schengen we would be less protected from terror. We would not get any important information,” she said, adding that those who seek to terminate the agreement are “irresponsible”. 
 
Britain is not a member of Schengen but does take part in the agreement’s information-sharing system.
 
The minister said she was shocked by the attack in London and that such events could also happen in Switzerland, which is why international collaboration is vital. 
 
“No one can manage their own security alone,” she said.
 
Even with such cooperation it is impossible to guarantee security in face of “low-cost” terror acts such as the one in London, she told the paper. 
 
“Any individual can do a lot of damage with little effort.” 
 
Consequently, it is important for the public to assist the authorities by reporting suspected cases of radicalization, she said.
 
“Radicalization often happens slowly, people change little by little,” she said. “The authorities are dependent on teachers, parents, friends to be attentive and, if necessary, to seek advice and assistance from local authorities”.
 
Switzerland should even look to make reporting suspected radicalized people an obligation, she added, though recognized that you cannot punish someone for a crime they haven’t yet committed. 
 
However in 2014 Switzerland imposed a ban on Islamic State (Isis), meaning it is a crime to support the terror group in any way, for example by posting online propaganda or trying to recruit new members.
 
Currently around 500 people in Switzerland are “on the radar” of the authorities for showing sympathy to Isis online, and around 60 are facing criminal proceedings, said Sommaruga. 
 
“The number of truly dangerous people is somewhere between those two figures.”
  

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

EUROPEAN UNION

How does being in EFTA and Schengen benefit people in Switzerland?

Switzerland is not a member of the European Union but it does have other agreements in place that give certain benefits to its citizens.

How does being in EFTA and Schengen benefit people in Switzerland?

While the country has steadfastly stayed out of the EU, its government has been pragmatic enough to realise that it can’t remain completely ‘neutral’ and miss out on all the perks that other European citizens take for granted — specifically, the Schengen area and EFTA (European Free Trade Association).

Let’s look at Schengen first

This treaty allows citizens of 27 European nations the free movement of people among participating countries.

Most of the Schengen countries are EU members, with only Switzerland, Norway, Iceland, and Liechtenstein — all of which belong to EFTA (read more about this below) — not in the European Union.

How did Switzerland get into Schengen?

Again, chalk it down to pragmatism.

Given its location right in the middle of Europe, and surrounded by EU-member states, Switzerland would be totally isolated if it did not join the borderless zone.

Therefore, the government signed a bilateral agreement with Brussels but, as any new legislation, it had to be approved in a referendum before going into effect.

As often happens when Switzerland seeks closer ties with the EU, the right-wing Swiss People’s Party (SVP) opposed the move.

However, it was approved by 55 percent of Swiss voters in 2005, and on December 12th, 2008, Switzerland formally joined Schengen

What are the benefits of this membership for residents of Switzerland?

Simply put, it allows anyone who is in Switzerland legally to enjoy hassle-free travel to and from the 26 other Schengen states, visa time limits permitting.

Travellers arriving into Switzerland for the first time from a non-Schengen state like the UK or the US will have to queue up to have their passports checked, but after that they can move freely.

That means Swiss citizens, EU nationals, non-EU international residents in Switzerland, tourists, exchange students or people travelling for business can travel on to another Schengen member state, perhaps neighbouring France or Germany by car or train, without having to show their passports. (Although occasionally checks are brought back.) 

That is a definite ‘plus’ for anyone who travels within Europe. Due to Switzerland having so many land borders with other Schengen countries it would have been hugely problematic not to join.

What about EFTA?

The four countries that opted to stay out of the European Union (Switzerland, Norway, Iceland, and Liechtenstein) belong to the European Free Trade Association, known as EFTA.

Its main goal is to promote free trade among the four countries and with the EU.

One feature of EFTA is that, in contrast to the EU, its four member states are economically prosperous, as well as expensive  — though none as much as Switzerland.

But since the EU, and primarily Germany, are Switzerland’s main trading partners, EFTA doesn’t carry quite as much weight overall.

There is, however, another advantage as well: its citizens can live and work in the each other’s countries without a visa, with work permits being granted easily (just as is the case for the EU, which Switzerland has a Free Movement of Persons Agreement).

But in terms of residency, Swiss nationals draw less benefit from EFTA than vice-versa.

Take, for instance, Norwegian citizens.

While only about 2,800 Swiss live in Norway, around 5,000 Norwegians have moved to Switzerland

The reason is simple: taxes.

Since tax rates in Norway are much higher than in Switzerland, dozens of wealthy Norwegians have moved to Switzerland in recent years.

READ ALSO: Why do rich Norwegians flee to Switzerland? 

So it is fair to say that one of EFTA’s benefits — in particular the freedom of movement — is that wealthy citizen of that country bring significant tax revenue to Swiss cantons where they live.

And what’s the deal with  Liechtenstein?

The tiny principality is one EFTA member that is most like Switzerland: its residents speak Swiss German and use Swiss franc as a currency.

Of the four nations it is also the only one that looks most like rural Switzerland — especially when it’s dark and raining, and it is difficult to distinguish one nation from another.

So much so, in fact, that the Swiss army even ‘invaded’ it on three occasions because they mistook Liechtenstain for Switzerland.

READ ALSO: How the army attacked Liechtenstein three times — by mistake

SHOW COMMENTS