SHARE
COPY LINK

EUROPEAN UNION

‘Stop telling expat Remainers to come home – it’s not that simple’

"Come home, then". This was a comment I received on Twitter a few nights ago in response to a point I had made about the situation of expats in the era of Brexit. Although curt, this comment was nothing like as rude as others that we 'remainers' have been subject to in recent months.

'Stop telling expat Remainers to come home - it's not that simple'
A man waves European Union and United Kingdom flags together at a London protest. Photo: Justin Tallis/AFP

When, I keep asking myself, did my tolerant and open country become intolerant and closed? It is a heartbreaking change to watch.

“Come home”: I'm afraid that for many expats, including me, the situation is not as simple as that. It is a myth that we are all slugging gin on sun loungers in sunny British enclaves and it is equally a myth that we are all rich.

It would not be financially possible for most of us to come home, and I am not the only one who would have nowhere to go in my native country.

Therefore, when we raise concerns about the future of our pensions or access to healthcare in the countries where we now live, they are real concerns; a freezing of our pensions would spell poverty in old age for thousands of us and the threat of cutting off our right to healthcare, at the time in our lives when we are likely to need it most, fills us with fear.

Now, before I am shot down by those who think that, having decided no longer to live in the “green and pleasant land”, I deserve everything that is – or, more likely, isn't – coming to me, and before I am told that, for the same reason, I have no right to any British pension at all , I would like to point out the following: I believe I served Britain tolerably well in my role as a teacher and then as a lecturer. The schools I taught in were far from élitist and I worked hard for my pension. 

With regard to healthcare, the agreement in place at the time I moved to Italy was one of entitlement because there is a reciprocal agreement in place for Italians living and working in Britain. I have never sponged off either system in my life. When you move to another country, you do so under a certain set of circumstances and you do not expect retrospective legislation to pull the rug out from under your British feet.

Incidentally, if the value of people's pensions had been cut by up to 25 percent in the UK , there would be uproar, yet this is exactly what has already happened to expats since the Brexit referendum and we are all afraid to say so publicly because we will be branded “selfish, élitist remoaners”. Well, it is about time someone said it and I do so here.

Another fear we have is that, even if a “right to stay” agreement is reached, it may be dependent upon some sort of property qualification. No, I am not restoring a castle or tending my vineyard – like many other expats, I pay my way but I do not own property in either country.

We do not figure in the British Prime Minister's narrow vision of the “JAMs” [families who are “just about managing”] but that is often the reality for expats. Oh, and I'm not out here with family, either – I am truly dispossessed!

Why, some of you may wonder, would anyone want to leave Britain in the first place? My answer is because I am a Modern Languages graduate and I fell in love with Italy at an early age.

Loving another country does not mean that you love your own any the less; in fact you can come to love it more, because you see it with new eyes from abroad. Moreover, having had the chance to teach in Italy, I believe I have contributed in my small way to the spreading of British culture here.

When the British state educated me and trained me as a teacher, it did not do so in order that I might live exclusively in one country or the other; it did so in order that I would have a choice. That's what education does. I was given the ability to make a choice and I made it, believing, like others, that I was protected in it by treaty.

That our native land now wants to rip that treaty up is hardly our fault and we are appalled by our formerly gentle nation's abandonment of its own citizens in the EU. This is not the Britain that I recognize and it is not the free and fair Britain that I have told so many Italian students about.

I am hurt, as I am sure other expats are hurt, by the name-calling we have had to endure: I am not a “remoaner”; I am merely someone who wishes to embrace more than one culture and my language skills have enabled me to do that fully. Where was I on the day that such a wish became a crime in Britain?

The general view in Britain seems to be that three million expats are just a few snail-eaters who do not matter and I have no information on how many of us still have voting rights there. But elections and referendums, as we have seen, can turn on very few votes.

Perhaps one day soon the British government will wake up to the fact that we matter. I hope it does not do so too late.

This opinion piece was originally posted on the blog, Sicily Scene: A Welshwoman's Life in Sicily. See the original post here.
 

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

POLITICS

Italy’s Meloni upstaged in Europe after challenging weeks

Italy's Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni has carved a reputation for herself as a leader and unifier of Europe's fractured far right, but political turmoil across the continent has shaken her position.

Italy's Meloni upstaged in Europe after challenging weeks

Meloni’s close ally Viktor Orban of Hungary has poached some of her backers in the European Parliament, and the far-right National Rally (RN) suffered an election humbling in France.

However, Italy’s most right-wing leader since the end of World War II may still have cards to play, analysts say.

READ ALSO: What does Meloni’s EU election success mean for foreigners in Italy?

Since coming to power in October 2022, she has toned down her Euroscepticism and fallen in line with most EU leaders by staunchly backing Ukraine in its fight against Russia.

And she has collaborated with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, helping calm nerves in Brussels.

But recent events, most notably the formation of a new bloc within the European Parliament founded by Orban, are now causing Meloni serious problems, say political watchers.

Add to that the surprise defeat of Marine Le Pen’s RN in French parliamentary elections on Sunday, and the victory of centre-left Labour in Britain, and the week for Meloni “certainly wasn’t good”, wrote La Stampa daily.

Meloni was fresh off a high in June when her European Conservatives and Reformists (ECR) bloc in the European Parliament gained new members to become the body’s third-largest faction.

She had displaced the bloc linked to France’s Emmanuel Macron – with whom she has frosty relations.

READ ALSO: Italy’s hard-right government demands top EU commission job

But the success turned sour on Monday when Orban’s Patriots for Europe grouping overtook the ECR as it accumulated parties – not only France’s RN but also poaching Spain’s Vox from Meloni’s camp.

“It’s bad news in terms of numbers but more importantly it’s bad news because they’ve stolen the limelight,” Daniele Albertazzi, a professor of politics at the University of Surrey, told AFP.

“They’ve clearly shaken up the agenda in the last week or two, they’ve managed to bring in very large parties.”

Political analyst Anna Bonalume said Vox’s defection “shows to what extent Giorgia Meloni has been weakened by this European series of events”.

Moreover, Orban made a surprise visit to Moscow last week that was widely criticised by Ukraine’s Western allies.

This could add to deteriorating relations with Meloni, who in the past has scored points in Brussels for extracting concessions from the Hungarian leader.

“If, following Orban’s visit to Moscow, there’s a definitive break with Orban, Meloni would be completely isolated in Europe,” Bonalume told AFP.

Another potential competitor emerged Thursday with the formation of a new far-right group, Europe of Sovereign Nations, led by Germany’s Alternative for Germany (AfD) party, fresh off its best-ever EU election result.

‘Playing the game’

The French election would not have pleased Meloni.

Italian media reported that she had counted on a Macron defeat to help in negotiating an influential role for Italy within the next European Commission, after being marginalised last month when leaders chose senior positions.

“But the bet didn’t work,” La Repubblica newspaper wrote.

On Tuesday, Meloni sought to put a positive spin on recent events, saying unstable governments were long a fixture in Italy, in contrast to stable ones enjoyed by its neighbours.

“Today we see an Italy with a very solid government in a Europe in which there are very unstable governments and this must make us proud,” she said on the sidelines of a NATO summit in Washington.

READ ALSO: Italy’s Meloni hopes EU ‘understands message’ from voters

Despite the professed strength of Italy’s government, the leader of the populist League, Matteo Salvini, continues to provoke his coalition partner Meloni without attacking her directly, having joined Orban’s grouping and calling it “determinant to change the future of this Europe”.

But Meloni, as leader of the EU’s third-largest economy, is capable of turning the recent setbacks to her advantage, Albertazzi said.

“It depends on how she plays the game,” he said.

“It’s not all bad news because it also helps Meloni strengthen her own narrative, which is ‘I am the responsible and moderate radical right’.”

And if Meloni manages to secure a top commissioner role for Italy, she can show she still has influence in Brussels.

“She’ll be able to say, ‘Those people over there make noise but I’m the one bringing about some change.'”

By AFP’s Ella Ide

SHOW COMMENTS