SHARE
COPY LINK

COURT

Court sides with chickens in dispute over noisy henhouse

A court in the canton of Vaud has ordered a man to pay more than 36,000 francs in court costs after it rejected his complaint that his neighbours’ chickens made too much noise.

Court sides with chickens in dispute over noisy henhouse
File photo: Stuart Richards

The saga dates back to 2010, when a couple bought a chalet in a rural area above Montreux with the intention of keeping chickens on its 4,000m2 parcel of land, reported 24 Heures on Wednesday.

Before buying the place the couple – named as Anouk and Philippe Michauville – checked they were able to keep chickens there and the commune confirmed they could, as long as their number didn’t surpass 2,000, said the paper.

But in 2012 a lawyer on behalf of their neighbour served them ten days’ notice to put an end to the “racket” made by the cockerels and hens.

The neighbour owned a place 50m above the couple’s chalet but actually lived in Zug and was only ever there a few weeks a year, the Michauvilles told the paper.

They did nothing to respond to the order, considering it an absurd request in a rural area, said the paper. But the following spring they received another legal letter on behalf of the neighbour claiming the noisy birds reduced the value of his house and demanding 97,000 francs in damages.

Despite keeping their cockerels inside at night to prevent them crowing, the row continued and went to a court hearing in March, where a number of measures were considered in an effort to resolve the dispute.

The neighbour agreed to renounce his claim for damages if the couple gave up their henhouse. But they refused, said 24 Heures.

Finally, six months after the hearing, the civil court rejected the neighbour’s case last week, ordering him to pay 21,642 francs in legal costs and 15,000 francs expenses.

He has not yet decided if he will appeal, reported the paper.

The issue of noise in the countryside crops up in Switzerland from time to time.

In May this year a farmer in the Zurich Oberland lost his appeal over his neighbours' complaints that the bells on his cows were too noisy at night.

The farmer was ordered to remove bells from any cow located within 200m of a house during the hours of 10pm and 7am.

At the time the farmer told the media he was ready to fight the issue in the supreme court.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

FARMING

Farmers dump sheep killed by wolves in front of Swiss government building

Swiss sheep farmers on Saturday dumped the bodies of animals killed by wolves in front of a regional government building, demanding more action against the predators, Swiss media reported.

Farmers dump sheep killed by wolves in front of Swiss government building

Around a dozen breeders came from the Saint-Barthelemy area in the western Swiss canton of Vaud to lay out the carcasses of 12 sheep in front of the regional government headquarters in Lausanne, the Chateau Saint-Maire.

“These sheep were killed last night,” Eric Herb, a member of a Swiss association demanding the regulation of big predators, was quoted as saying by the Keystone-ATS news agency.

“It is really time to act.”

“We are sick of this. We want the wolf killed,” agreed Patrick Perroud, a farmer and butcher from the nearby municipality of Oulens.

“Cohabitation is not possible. Our territory is too small,” he told Keystone-ATS.

The protesters told the news agency that wolves had killed 17 sheep in the same area late last month, two earlier this week and 13 overnight to Saturday.

“The breeders have played nice until now, but this time it was too much,” Herb said.

The protesters were planning to increase the pressure on the Vaud government environment minister, Vassilis Venizelos of the Green Party, he said.

One of the protesters’ banners read: “Vassilis step down”, Keystone-ATS reported.

The breeders had briefly negotiated with regional police before being allowed to lay down the animal carcasses on tarpaulin in front of the Chateau.

Participants in the protest, which was supported by the regional chapter of the far-right Swiss People’s Party — Switzerland’s largest party — lamented that they were losing sleep.

“We have to check on our animals every night,” one was quoted as saying.

After being wiped out more than a century ago, wolves have in recent decades begun returning to Switzerland and to several other European countries.

Since the first pack was spotted in the wealthy Alpine nation in 2012, the number of packs swelled to 32 last year, with around 300 individual wolves counted.

Nature conservation groups have hailed the return as a sign of a healthier and more diverse ecosystem.

But breeders and herders complain of attacks on livestock and have been ramping up demands to cull more wolves.

Swiss authorities last year relaxed the rules for hunting the protected species, and decided to allow large preventative culls in the most affected cantons but swift legal actions put those plans partially on ice.

The debate in several parts of Europe about wolves rose up the political agenda in September.

In an open letter to the European Commission, eight leading conservation groups said there were ways to make coexistence easier between humans and large wild animals like wolves.

“Damage to livestock is often linked to the lack of adequate supervision and/or physical protection,” they said. They pointed to strategies such as “the training of dogs to protect herds, education of herders, tools and technical solutions to deter wolves”.

SHOW COMMENTS