SHARE
COPY LINK

RAIL

Woman seeks compensation for wetting herself on train

A woman from southern Germany wet herself when the only toilet on her train was out of order. A court case on Friday will hear whether German Rail (DB) should pay up.

Woman seeks compensation for wetting herself on train
Photo: Wikipedia Commons

The journey took place in October 2014 between Koblenz and Trier and has been described by the woman in question as two hours of torture.

She urgently needed the toilet but the only one on the train was out of order.

Unable to relieve herself, she had to suffer in painful silence for two hours until the train arrived at Trier train station, her lawyer has said.

When the train finally arrived, the woman rushed out to use the station toilet, but unfortunately she didn’t make it in time.

Because of this most uncomfortable and embarrassing of experiences, the woman sued rail operator DB for €400.

A court in Trier sided with her in July and ordered to DB to pay the woman €200.

The state-owned train company had failed in its duty twofold, the judges ruled. Firstly, it had not provided a functioning toilet and secondly it had not given passengers a viable alternative.

But despite the minuscule amount of money being demanded, DB are refusing to pay, and on Friday a court of appeal will hear their case.

“In principle there is a toilet on our trains, but we are of the opinion that passengers don’t have a legal right to have one,” the rail operator's lawyer said.

According to consumer group Pro Bahn, DB doesn’t want to cough up the money “because they see it as setting a precedent.”

It is true that passengers don’t have a right to a toilet on regional trains, but there is a “right to have what you are accustomed to”, Pro Bahn’s Karl-Peter Naumann argued.

This isn’t the first time that DB has left passengers exposed after not taking care of their loos, Naumann added.

A year or two ago, when the toilet on a train in the Rhine region was broken, the train company gave a man a bucket to do his business into, Naumann recalls.

As German society becomes ever older, it is more urgent than ever that proper, working toilets are provided on trains, since pensioners are more regular visitors to the rest room than most, Naumann says.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

TRAVEL

Could Oslo-Copenhagen overnight train be set for return?

A direct overnight rail service between the Norwegian and Danish capitals has not operated since 2001, but authorities in Oslo are considering its return.

Norway’s transport minister Knut Arild Hareide has asked the country’s railway authority Jernbanedirektoratet to investigate the options for opening a night rail connection between Oslo and Copenhagen.

An answer is expected by November 1st, after which the Norwegian government will decide whether to go forward with the proposal to directly link the two Nordic capitals by rail.

Jernbanedirektoratet is expected to assess a timeline for introducing the service along with costs, market and potential conflicts with other commercial services covering the route.

“I hope we’ll secure a deal. Cross-border trains are exciting, including taking a train to Malmö, Copenhagen and onwards to Europe,” Hareide told Norwegian broadcaster NRK.

The minister said he envisaged either a state-funded project or a competition awarding a contract for the route’s operation to the best bidder.

A future Oslo-Copenhagen night train rests on the forthcoming Jernbanedirektoratet report and its chances of becoming a reality are therefore unclear. But the Norwegian rail authority earlier this year published a separate report on ways in which passenger train service options from Norway to Denmark via Sweden can be improved.

“We see an increasing interest in travelling out of Norway by train,” Jernbanedirektoratet project manager  Hanne Juul said in a statement when the report was published in January.

“A customer study confirmed this impression and we therefore wish to make it simpler to take the train to destinations abroad,” Juul added.

Participants in the study said that lower prices, fewer connections and better information were among the factors that would encourage them to choose the train for a journey abroad.

Norway’s rail authority also concluded that better international cooperation would optimise cross-border rail journeys, for example by making journey and departure times fit together more efficiently.

The Femahrn connection between Denmark and Germany, currently under construction, was cited as a factor which could also boost the potential for an overland rail connection from Norway to mainland Europe.

Night trains connected Oslo to Europe via Copenhagen with several departures daily as recently as the late 1990s, but the last such night train between the two cities ran in 2001 amid dwindling demand.

That trend has begun to reverse in recent years due in part to an increasing desire among travellers to select a greener option for their journey than flying.

Earlier this summer, a new overnight train from Stockholm to Berlin began operating. That service can be boarded by Danish passengers at Høje Taastrup near Copenhagen.

READ ALSO: What you need to know about the new night train from Copenhagen to Germany

SHOW COMMENTS