SHARE
COPY LINK

ANIMAL

Animal activists call for Palio ban after horse dies

Animal rights groups have called for Italy's most famous horse race, the Palio di Siena, to be banned after the death of a horse during a warm-up heat.

Animal activists call for Palio ban after horse dies
Horses run around the makeshift racetrack. Fabio Muzzi / AFP

Concerns were raised after the death of a horse, called Periclea, during trials for this year's Palio on Monday.

She fell and broke her front right foot during an early heat for the first race, which will be held on July 2nd.

The seven-year-old filly fell at the first corner of the San Martino curve after tripping over the legs of the horse in front, La Stampa reported. It was set to be Periclea's first Palio, but the mare had already competed in similar events including the Palio di Ferrara in May.

The animal was given immediate treatment and taken to a local veterinary clinic – but her injuries, which included a broken foot, were too severe for her to be saved.

“This is the umpteenth death that could have been avoided by stopping this shameful and bloody event,” a member of animal rights group, Partito Animalista Europeo, told La Stampa.

“Our legal office have sent a cease and desist order to the prefect of Siena as well as to interior minister Angelino Alfano to call for the suspension of the event.”

It is unlikely their attempts to stop the race, which started in its modern form in 1656, will be successful.

However, according to the Anti-Vivisection League, 48 horses died at the Palio between 1970 and 2007. More stringent laws regarding safety were brought in the 1990s, including alcohol tests for jockeys, but horses continue to die during the event.

The famous race is held twice a years on July 2nd and August 16th, and lasts about 90 seconds. Riding bareback, the jockeys circle the Piazza del Campo three times and are frequently thrown from their horses.

During the Palio of August 16th 2004 the horse running for the ward of Bruco fell and was trampled to death, which brought complaints from animal rights groups as well as concerns for the safety of the riders.

For the occasion of the Palio, the Piazza is filled with turf and dirt in order to form a racetrack. It is a hugely popular event among both locals and tourists and draws crowds of 50,000 people.

The race has deep traditions in Siena, but is fiercely competed by neighbouring districts of the city, which often employ underhand tactics, such as bribery and doping, to try and get the upper hand.

During the race the jockeys shove, whip and distract their fiercest rivals to try and stop them from gaining the coveted prize, which is an embroidered silk banner known as a Palio, from which the race derives its name.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

REFERENDUM

Will foreigners in Switzerland finally earn the right to vote in federal elections?

In an ongoing effort to include foreign nationals in Switzerland’s political decisions, one party is proposing granting voting rights to foreign nationals in federal elections. It submitted the project on Monday, while the parliament is in its spring session.

Will foreigners in Switzerland finally earn the right to vote in federal elections?
Swiss party calls for voting rights for foreigners. Photo by Fabrice Coffrini / AFP

What is this parliamentary proposal and who is spearheading it?

It seeks to allow political rights to people of foreign nationality, including the right to vote and be elected at the federal level.

An estimated 1.5 foreigners living in Switzerland “should have the right to participate in decision-making in the country in which they reside, often for a very long time.

A democracy that takes diversity into account carries more weight”, said the Green Party, which is spearheading the campaign. 

Do foreigners already have any voting rights in Switzerland?

Some cantons and communes give their resident foreigners the right to vote on local issues and to elect local politicians, according to the Swiss Federal Statistical Office (FSO). 

But as Switzerland is a federal state, “there are considerable differences between cantons, and in some cases, between communes. As a result, the opportunities for political participation are strongly dependent on where a person lives”, FSO said.

READ MORE: Jobs in Switzerland: Foreigners ‘less likely to be hired than Swiss nationals’ 

The Swiss-French cantons and municipalities seem to be ahead of their German-speaking counterparts in regards to voting rights.

The cantons of Fribourg, Vaud, Neuchâtel and Jura allow non-citizens to vote, elect officials, and stand for election at communal level. Conditions vary from one canton to another, but in most cases a certain length of stay and/or a residence permit are required.

In Vaud, for instance, where 30 percent of the population is foreign, immigrants can run for or sit on the communal or Town Council, as well as sign an initiative or a communal referendum.

‘I pay taxes but have no say in Swiss life’: Your views on whether Switzerland should allow all foreigners to vote

However, in order to be eligible, they must be over 18 years of age (just like Swiss citizens), hold a residence permit for at least 10 years, and live in the canton for at least three years. 

All foreign nationals are directly entered in the electoral register once the requirements are met, and automatically receive the official material for votes and elections on a communal level. 

Geneva, which has the largest foreign population in Switzerland (45 percent), grants foreigners voting rights at communal level, but they can’t run for office. 

Basel, Graubünden, and Appenzell Ausserrhoden have authorised their communes to introduce the right to vote, the right to elect .and the right to be elected. 

But few of the communes have actually introduced these measures.

In Graubünden, only 10 of the canton’s 208 municipalities are allowing foreigners to vote: Bever, Bonaduz, Calfreise, Cazis, Conters im Prättigau, Fideris, Lüen, Masein, Portein, and Schnaus.

Only three of Appenzell Ausserrhoden’s 20 municipalities— Wald, Speicher, and Trogen — granted voting rights to non-citizens.

What are the chances of this proposal actually succeeding?

As the parliament is in session only until March 19th and its agenda is full, it could possibly debate the issue in its summer or fall session.

But even if the proposal gets parliamentary approval, the issue will have to be ultimately decided in a referendum, and conservative groups like Swiss People’s Party (SVP) would most likely oppose it.

Paradoxically, foreigners will not be able to vote on whether they should they have the right to vote.

READ MORE: Switzerland marks 50 years of women voting 

SHOW COMMENTS