SHARE
COPY LINK
CANNES FILM FESTIVAL

CANNES FILM FESTIVAL

Cannes judges were too France-friendly: Italians

Three of Italy's most acclaimed film directors left Cannes empty-handed at the weekend, prompting criticism of the festival's "Francophile" judges in the Italian press.

Cannes judges were too France-friendly: Italians
Italian directors Nanni Moretti (L), Paolo Sorrentino (C) and Matteo Garrone (R) all walked away empty handed from Cannes. Photos: AFP

With three films in the official line-up, Italy was one of the strongest contingents in the Cannes Film Festival, along with France which had five films in the Palme d'Or race.

But on Sunday Italian directors Paolo Sorrentino, Matteo Garrone and Nanni Moretti – dubbed “the three musketeers” in the Italian press – left the competition empty-handed.

The coveted Palme d’Or was captured by the French film Dheepan, a thriller spotlighting the plight of traumatized refugees building new lives.

France also won big in other categories with the prize of best actor going to Vincent Lindon for his role as a job-seeker trying to preserve his dignity in The Measure of a Man, while the best actress award was won by Emmanuelle Bercot for her part in the doomed romance Mon Roi (My King).

Bercot split the prize with Rooney Mara, who was paired in the American lesbian love story Carol with more hotly tipped co-star Cate Blanchett.

The best director honour went to Taiwan's Hou Hsiao-Hsien for the lush, slow-burn martial arts film The Assassin.

The absence of Italian winners this year was greeted with bitterness and disappointment by the Italian media, with Italian daily La Stampa branding the judges “Francophiles”.

“The Festival reconfirms itself as a place of research, but this time, too excessively, as a place of extreme promotion of home-grown cinema,” read the article published on Monday.

“If it had happened at the Venice Film Festival, someone would speak out, who knows what they would have accused us of.”

Italy’s La Repubblica newspaper was also critical, accusing the jury, which was led by the Coen brothers, of veering away from the opinion of critics, reporters and the public. 

“The difficult situation in the world (including the economic crisis and terrorism) may have influenced the jury who chose titles with social issues: unemployment, emigration, war, the Holocaust,” read an article also published on Monday.

Italy’s culture minister Dario Franceschini, meanwhile, was more gracious about the defeat.

“Cannes is a great festival even when Italians don’t win. It’s a duty to be there: France and Italy together are European cinema,” he tweeted at the end of the ceremony.

In line with a broader Cannes trend, two of the three Italian films in the line-up were made in English this year.

They included Youth by Oscar winner Sorrentino, which features an all-star UK and US cast: Michael Caine, Jane Fonda, Rachel Weisz, Harvey Keitel and Paul Dano.

The second, The Tale of Tales, by Garrone (who won the Grand Prize in 2008 for Gomorra), stars Salma Hayek and Vincent Cassel in a fantasy collection of three fables.

Only Moretti, a Cannes darling who won the Palme in 2001 for The Son's Room, sticks mostly to Italian with his semi-autobiographical My Mother – but even then, US-Italian actor John Turturro adds some of the international lingua franca to the mix.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

CANNES FILM FESTIVAL

Cannes festivalgoers fall for ‘gloriously sweet’ Norwegian film

The Cannes film festival has fallen head over heels for a Norwegian film about a young woman trying to find herself and the unknown actress who plays her.

Cannes festivalgoers fall for 'gloriously sweet' Norwegian film
Actress Renate Reinsve poses for photographers on arrival for the premiere of the film "The Worst Person In The World" at the 74th Cannes International Film Festival. Photo: picture alliance/dpa/AP | Vadim Ghirda

“A star is born,” declared The Guardian’s Peter Bradshaw.

Renate Reinsve “takes off like a rocket and deserves star status to rival Lily James or Alicia Vikander,” he added, giving “The Worst Person in the World” a five-star review – one of several it has already garnered.

In her first big screen lead, Reinsve plays a twenty-something trying and failing to define herself through her pinballing relationships with men until she finally strikes out on her own path.

Variety predicted it would become a “touchstone” movie for millennials, Britain’s Daily Telegraph called it “wondrous”, while Xan Brooks of The Observer said it was “simply gorgeous”.

‘A whole new genre’

Bradshaw – one of several critics to admit wiping away a tear or two during the premiere – credited the director Joachim Trier with inventing a whole new genre.

“Trier has taken on one of the most difficult genres imaginable, the romantic drama, and combined it with another very tricky style – the
coming-of-ager – to craft something gloriously sweet and beguiling,” he said.

READ ALSO: Mission possible: Norway relaxes quarantine rules for Tom Cruise and film crew

The French media were equally bewitched.

And everyone wondered why the world has never heard of 33-year-old Reinsve before.

Trier told AFP that “there is an awful lot of her in the character. She has had a big, big impact on this film.”


Norwegian actress Renate Reinsve (L) and Danish director Joachim Trier pose during a photocall at Cannes on July 9th, 2021. Photo: Valery HACHE / AFP

“I wrote it specifically for her,” he added, citing her gift for  improvisation. “I could cut four of five different versions of any scene with her in this film.

“I always wondered why the hell is Norwegian film so messed up that she hasn’t had a lead role yet?” 

Love in the time of #MeToo

Reinsve told AFP that she had “been through the same” labyrinth of self-doubt and indecision as her character.

And she too would often think of herself as the worst person in the world as she saw others around fly.

In the film her character Julie drifts from medical school to a psychology degree to photography to five minutes of Facebook fame for writing a piece called “Oral sex in the era of #MeToo”.

“Growing up before #MeToo you kind of shape yourself with the strong opinions and presence of men,” Reinsve added.

“She finds her identity in others’ eyes. When you free yourself from that, you become yourself and stronger,” she said.

The film – which includes one of the most gobsmackingly feminist sex scenes ever seen at Cannes – has also been praised for the way it deals with the shifting gender power balance.

In one particularly telling scene, Reinsve’s older graphic novelist boyfriend crashes and burns when a radio interview turns to the lumpen sexism of his past creations.

READ ALSO: Sweden’s feminists launch in Norway

Trier said the film was navigating “the beautiful chaos” and complications of love in a time of massive change.

“With #MeToo it is very polarised. But I believe that change also comes about through humanity and understanding,” he said.

“Is there such a thing as pure love? I’m not sure, they are millions of agendas, conscious and unconscious.

“I want to give a big hug to people with this the film and say hey, ‘It’s OK. we are all going through this.'”

“The Worst Person in the World” is one of 24 films competing for Cannes’ top prize, the Palme d’Or, which will be awarded next Saturday.

SHOW COMMENTS