SHARE
COPY LINK

ACCIDENT

Fatal Alps bus crash blamed on ‘brake failure’

A French prosecutor investigating a fatal bus crash in the Alps in which the British driver of the vehicle was killed and four passengers seriously injured said brake failure was the probable cause. The driver has been praised for his courage.

Fatal Alps bus crash blamed on 'brake failure'
A fire-fighter stands near the wreckage of the bus in question, near the Alpe d'Huez resort in Isère. One person has died and four are seriously injured. Photo: Jean-Pierre Clatot/AFP

The bus which belonged to British company Classic Coaches was carrying young Britons aged mostly in their 20s, who had just finished working during the skiing season. It was travelling down a road from the popular resort of Alpe d'Huez when it hit a cliff face at turn 21at around 1.45pm on Tuesday. It is not clear what caused the accident but investigators believed brake failure was the probable cause.

"It is very probably an issue with the brakes. Now the question is why and the investigation is likely to take a long time," Grenoble prosecutor
Jean-Yves Coquillat told AFP.

According to passenger accounts, the British driver had shouted out that the brakes were not working as the coach hurtled towards the last of a series of 21 treacherous hairpin bends that regularly feature in the Tour de France cycling race.

The driver has been praised for his "remarkable courage" which "saved many lives." Four of the coach's passengers – British seasonal workers – were left seriously injured.

The bus which belonged to British company Classic Coaches was carrying young Britons aged mostly in their 20s, who had just finished working during the skiing season. It was travelling down a road from the popular resort of Alpe d'Huez when it hit a cliff face at turn 21. It is not clear what caused the accident.

"The bus was going down. The driver had time to warn passengers that he had a problem. He hit a parapet and the bus caught fire," said Jean Rampon, an official from the prefect of Isère, the department where Alpe d'Huez is located.

The driver, based in the North East of England died in the crash, four others were seriously injured and 22 more slightly hurt. 

After visiting survivors of the deadly crash at the CHU hospital in Grenoble on Tuesday evening, French junior minister for transport Frédéric Cuvillier emphasized the "remarkable courage" of the vehicle's driver, that "allowed many lives to be saved," French daily Le Dauphiné Liberé reported.

"Every account from everyone we've met confirms that his attitude and his actions prevented the death toll from being heavier," said Cuvillier, who was accompanied on the visit by Britain's Ambassador in France, Sir Peter Ricketts.

Neither Cuvillier nor Ricketts would give details on the sequence of events which led to the fatal accident, nor the actions taken by the driver to minimize harm to the vehicle's passengers. 

"The investigation is now ongoing," Cuvillier simply said, at a press conference on Tuesday evening.

An officer from the gendarmerie told The Local yesterday that claims the vehicles brakes had failed were just "suppositions". Other residents in the resort told The Local they had heard a truck may have been involved.

UK coach operator TGM also confirmed in a statement that the Classic Coaches service was en route from Serre Chevalier to various UK drop off points.

"We are deeply saddened to learn that one of our two drivers on board has died. We are offering our full support to his family and our thoughts are with them at this difficult time. He will be sadly missed by everyone at Classic Coaches," said Heath Williams, managing director of TGM.

“A number of passengers have sustained injuries and our thoughts are with them as they recover.”

“It is too early to say what caused the accident, however, we have launched a full investigation and are working closely with the local authorities.  Our own safety specialist is attending the scene to support the investigation.”

A statement by the Brighton-based travel company Skibound confirmed to The Local that the coach's passengers "had been on their way home after finishing their ski season working for Skibound in various ski resorts across the French Alps." 

A rescue worker described a scene of panic, with many passengers screaming, and reports claimed that at the site of the crash, suitcases lay wide-open next to the charred carcass of the bus with burnt clothes scattered all around.

Three of those who were seriously injured were flown to University Hospital in Grenoble by helicopter, while dozens of firemen and police were dispatched to the scene.

The road leading down from Alpe d'Huez is well known for its 21 treacherous, hairpin bends, and regularly features in the Tour de France cycling race. 

British ski instructor Stuart Adamson from Masterclass British Ski School told The Local: "The resort is in shock. We don't get many fatalities on the roads. French roads are often covered in wreaths where people have died, but not here.

"Its not a notorious road for accidents. Its not a race track, each turn has to be carefully negotiated. Its like an obstacle course."

This aerial satellite photo of a possible route down the mountainside from L'Alpe d'Huez (Point A) to Avenue des Jardins, (Point B) illustrates how sharply winding the descent is.

Tuesday's accident is not the first time this winter that seasonal workers from Skibound have been involved in tragedy at the Alpe d'Huez resort. In January, The Local reported the death of 19-year-old Lucy Sallis from Bognor Regis who drowned in a pool at the resort.   

There have been several deadly coach crashes on the winding roads of the Alps in recent years.

The most serious one was in July 2007, when 26 Polish pilgrims were killed and 14 others seriously injured when their coach – which was on a very steep stretch of road –  crashed into a ravine and burst into flames.

Last September was also a particularly devastating month for coach crashes in France, with two separate bus accidents killing three people – including a baby – and injuring more than 40 others.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

ACCIDENT

Cable car survivor must be returned to family in Italy, Israel court rules

An Israeli court ruled Monday that a boy whose parents died in an Italian cable car crash be returned to family in Italy, after his grandfather was accused of illegally bringing him to Israel.

Aya Biran , a paternal aunt of Eitan Biran who was the sole survivor of a deadly cable car crash in Italy, arrives at Tel Aviv’s Justice Court on October 10, 2021
Aya Biran , a paternal aunt of Eitan Biran who was the sole survivor of a deadly cable car crash in Italy, arrives at Tel Aviv’s Justice Court on October 10, 2021. Ahmad GHARABLI / AFP

The battle for custody of Eitan Biran, the sole survivor of the May accident that killed 14 people, has captured headlines since his maternal grandfather, Shmulik Peleg, brought him to Israel on a private jet last month.

The child lost his parents, younger brother and great-grandparents in the May 23 accident near the top of the Mottarone mountain in the northwestern Piedmont region, where the family was out on a Sunday excursion to the scenic spot served by the cable car.

The cable car’s pull cable snapped just before it reached destination. It then flew backwards, dislodging itself from a second, supporting cable, and crashed to the ground.

Investigations later revealed that emergency brakes that could have stopped the car on its supporting cable, avoiding the tragedy, had been deliberately deactivated to avoid delays following a technical malfunction.

Three individuals responsible for the cable car’s management were subsequently arrested.

The wreckage of a cable car that crashed on the slopes of the Mottarone peak above Stresa, Piedmont on May 23, 2021, killing 14.

The wreckage of a cable car that crashed on the slopes of the Mottarone peak above Stresa, Piedmont on May 23, 2021, killing 14. MIGUEL MEDINA / AFP.

Peleg has insisted that he drove Eitan from Italy to Switzerland before jetting him back to Israel – instead of returning him paternal aunt Aya Biran, who lives in northern Italy – because Eitan’s late parents wanted him to be raised in the Jewish state.

But Peleg has become the subject kidnapping probe by Italian prosecutors and Israeli police questioned him over those allegations last month.

A statement Monday from the Tel Aviv court where Aya Biran had filed a complaint said judges “did not accept the grandfather’s claim that the aunt has no custody rights”.

It recognised an Italian judgement that established Biran as a legitimate guardian and said Peleg had “unlawfully” removed the boy from his aunt’s care.

The court “ordered the return of the minor to his usual place of residence in Italy”.

The court also found that “a connection” between the surviving members of the Italy- and Israel-based relatives was in Eitan’s “best interests”.

Peleg was also ordered to pay Biran’s legal fees, amounting to 70,000 shekels ($22,000).

READ ALSO:

Shmuel Peleg, the grandfather of Eitan Biran, hugs a relative outside the Justice Court in the Israeli coastal city of Tel Aviv on October 8, 2021.

Shmuel Peleg, the grandfather of Eitan Biran, hugs a relative outside the Justice Court in the Israeli coastal city of Tel Aviv on October 8, 2021. Ahmad GHARABLI / AFP

The case has stirred emotions in Israel, and throngs of journalists had surrounded the Tel Aviv court for hearings last month, with some pro-Peleg protesters insisting it was wrong to send a Jewish child out of Israel.

Before judges ordered the sides to stop talking to the media, Peleg told Israel’s Channel 12 in September that his grandson was “in the place where he is supposed to be, in his home, in Israel.”

Eitan and his parents, Amit Biran and Tal Peleg, had been living in Italy, where Amit Biran was studying medicine, together with their other child, Tom.

Eitan suffered severe chest and abdominal injuries and spent a week in intensive care after the May accident that occurred when a cable snapped on the aerial tram bringing weekend visitors to the top of the Piedmont region’s Mottarone mountain.

The accident was one of Italy’s worst in over two decades.   

SHOW COMMENTS