Comments made by a member of parliament in Nicolas Sarkozy's UMP party have caused anger and prompted calls from fellow party members that he should be punished.

"/> Comments made by a member of parliament in Nicolas Sarkozy's UMP party have caused anger and prompted calls from fellow party members that he should be punished.

" />
SHARE
COPY LINK

FRAN

French MP: gays were never deported by Nazis

Comments made by a member of parliament in Nicolas Sarkozy's UMP party have caused anger and prompted calls from fellow party members that he should be punished.

French MP: gays were never deported by Nazis
libertepolitique.com

Christian Vanneste is an MP for the northern Nord region of France who has often spoken out about gay rights.

In the video, which was put online on Tuesday evening with the title “favouring the family to prepare for the future” (favoriser la famille pour préparer l’avenir), Vanneste talks about the “famous legend of the deportation of homosexuals.” 

Homosexuals were among those targeted by the Nazi party in Germany with thousands sent to concentration camps where many died.

Historians believe that homosexuals were also deported from France, particularly from some eastern regions which were annexed by Germany. 

Vanneste acknowledges that gays were persecuted by the Nazis, but claims that “apart from these three annexed departments, there were no deportations of homosexuals from France.”

The comments immediately sparked a wave of criticsm across the political spectrum.

The secretary general of the UMP, of which Vanneste is a member, Jean-François Copé, said he “would not shirk his responsibilities” in demanding sanctions about the remarks.

He said in a press conference that the party “unanimously condemns, with the greatest force, these unacceptable statements which are profoundly shocking and intolerable.”

“We have taken the decision to discuss the exclusion of Christian Vanneste from the UMP at our next meeting on Wednesday,” he said. In the meantime, he said the MP would be “immediately suspended from standing in the legislative elections.” These are scheduled for June.

Emmanuel Blanc, president of Gaylib, a gay organisation within the UMP party, said Vanneste “speaks about homosexuals in the way people spoke about Jews in the 1930s.”

Ohter ministers took to Twitter to condemn the remarks, including Nadine Morano, the minister for apprenticeships, who called for his expulsion from the party.

Criticism of the remarks crossed party lines. A spokeswoman for the Socialist presidential candidate, François Hollande, said President Nicolas Sarkozy should condemn the “nauseating ideology.”

On the far-right, the Front National said Mr Vanneste had his history wrong.

“Mr Vanneste needs to re-read his history books. This is really foolish,” said Louis Aliot, vice-president of the party.

In the twenty-minute video Vanneste also offers his analysis of homosexuality, claiming one of its main features is “narcissism.”

“Fundamental to homosexuality is narcissism,” he said. “The foundation is “I refuse the other”, the refusal of the opposite sex.”

He goes on to offer further analysis, for example that gay men prefer partners who “resemble them when they were between 17 and 20 years old.” He also refers to gay marriage as an “anthropological abberration.”

He then complains that a high number of gay people in the media, arts and communications has given gay causes a high profile, out of proportion “with the role that it has in the wider public, where it continues to be extremely marginalised.”

Gay issues have become a major feature of the presidential campaign following François Hollande’s commitment to legalise same-sex marriage and Nicolas Sarkozy’s promise to oppose it.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

SAME-SEX MARRIAGE

Same-sex couples can marry from July 1st in Switzerland

Same-sex couples will be permitted to get married in Switzerland on July 1st, 2022, nine months after a historic referendum.

Two grooms in suits with red heart balloons stand in front of a large heart which reads 'Same love, same rights' in German. Photo: Fabrice COFFRINI / AFP
Two grooms in suits with red heart balloons stand in front of a large heart which reads 'Same love, same rights' in German. Photo: Fabrice COFFRINI / AFP

On September 26th, 2021, Switzerland voted to legalise same-sex marriage, becoming one of the last countries in western Europe to do so. 

Nine months after the vote, the “marriage for all” law will enter into force as of July 1st, 2022, the Federal Council announced.

From this date on, gay couples will be able to marry, though the preparatory procedure for marriage can be started before this date.

Same-sex couples will also be able to convert their registered partnership into marriage: a simple joint declaration to a civil status officer will suffice to convert a current partnership.

READ MORE:UPDATE: Swiss voters say big ‘yes’ to same-sex marriage

This law will be enacted after 64 percent of Swiss voters backed the move in a September 26th nationwide referendum.

Lengthy battle

Switzerland decriminalised homosexuality in 1942, but numerous local and regional police forces continued to keep “gay registers”, some into the early 1990s.

Same-sex couples can already register a civil partnership, with around 700 established each year.

However, this status does not provide the same rights as marriage, including for obtaining citizenship and the joint adoption of children.

READ MORE: ‘Deviance and morality’: The history of the same-sex marriage movement in Switzerland

After years of debate and discussion, the Swiss parliament approved a bill last December allowing same-sex couples to marry in the country of 8.6 million people.

But it was challenged under Switzerland’s direct democracy system, with opponents gathering the 50,000 signatures needed to put the issue to a referendum.

SHOW COMMENTS