Read news from:
Austria
SHARE
COPY LINK

ELECTION

Macron accused of transphobia after lashing out at French left

French President Emmanuel Macron on Wednesday faced accusations of transphobia after lashing out at the snap election manifesto of a new left-wing coalition, in particular a proposal allowing citizens to change their gender at the town hall.

Published: 19 June 2024 11:06 CEST
Macron accused of transphobia after lashing out at French left
French President Emmanuel Macron on the campaign trail. Photo by Christophe Ena / POOL / AFP

The emergence of the Nouveau Front Populaire – an alliance of the four biggest left-wing parties – has been an unwelcome development for Macron since he called the snap elections in response to his party’s defeat by the far right in European polls.

His ruling alliance is forecast by opinion polls to come only third in the legislative elections on June 30th – followed by a second round on July 7th – behind the Rassemblement National (RN) and the new left-wing alliance.

But Macron said Tuesday on a visit to western France that he “had confidence in the French”.

“They see well what is on offer. The RN and its allies offer things which may make people happy but in the end we are talking €100 billion a year.”

“And on the other side, with the extreme left it’s four times worse – there is no more secularism they will go back on the immigration law and there are things that are completely farcical like changing your gender at the town hall,” he added.

The left-wing coalition’s programme includes a proposal allowing the change of civil status in a town hall.

Andy Kerbrat of the far-left La France Insoumise party told gay magazine Têtu this week that changing gender would be possible by filing a request at the town hall.

At present the process to be legally recognised as the opposite sex must in

volve an application submitted to a court, and the applicant must be an adult or emancipated minor.

Reader question: Do French people change their pronouns?

The person must demonstrate that the gender listed in their identification documents (ie birth or marriage certificates) does not match the gender they identify with – this might be done via testimony from friends and family, or even photos. Since 2016, it has no longer been required to reference any ongoing or past medical treatment.

Macron’s remarks appeared to cause disquiet even in the ranks of his own ruling Renaissance party.

“For trans people, for LGBT people, for everyone… we must reject all stigmatisation in political discourse and advance rights,” Renaissance MP Clément Beaune wrote on X.

“Emmanuel Macron is using transphobia to attack the programmes of his political opponents,” said Julia Torlet of NGO SOS Homophobie.

“The strategy is clear: use minorities in the race for power,” she added.

His comments also sparked an immediate counter-attack from left-wing opponents.

Socialist Party leader Olivier Faure said: “How is it possible that this man who was elected and re-elected to confront the extreme right is in reality repeating the discourse of the extreme right?”

Communist Party chief Fabien Roussel told Franceinfo that the comments were a sign Macron was “losing his nerve”.

“I sense a bit of febrility,” he said.

The comments marked a rare intervention by Macron in the campaign, which is being led for the ruling centrist alliance by 35-year-old Prime Minister Gabriel Attal, with multiple voices within Renaissance encouraging the president to keep a lower profile.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

FRENCH ELECTIONS

Explained: How France’s two-round voting system works

In most countries, voters head to the ballot boxes just once - in France, however, there are two polling days. Here's how the country's unusual two-round voting system works.

Published: 27 June 2024 08:36 CEST
Explained: How France's two-round voting system works

Most French elections are voted on in a two-round system.

Local, regional, parliamentary and presidential elections all have two rounds – the exception is the European elections, because they must conform to the voting patterns of the rest of Europe.

French Senate elections are another kettle of fish entirely.

Therefore in French domestic elections – including the current snap parliamentary elections – a range of candidates compete in the premier tour (first round) and voters can choose their favourite.

The highest-scoring candidates from the first round progress to the second round (deuxième tour) and voters go back to the polls to pick their favourite, or at any rate the one they dislike the least.

Votes are not carried forward from round one, so round two is a blank slate. At each round, voters can only choose one candidate. Most people vote in both rounds, but it’s possible to vote in only round one or only round two.

Outright winners

It can happen, though, that no second round takes place. If one candidate wins more than 50 percent of the vote then they are the outright winner (although in parliamentary elections they must also have got 25 percent of the total voters on the electoral roll, a measure intended to guard against shock results in elections with very low turnouts).

This is relatively common in municipal or regional elections. In parliamentary elections, it happens in a handful of constituencies but is rare. It has never happened in a presidential election.

Second round candidates

Exactly who goes through to the second round varies slightly depending on the type of election.

In presidential elections it is simple – the two highest scorers go through.

In legislative and municipal elections the two highest scorers go through, plus anyone else who has achieved at least 12.5 percent of the vote. Second rounds are usually two-horse races but in legislative elections there can be second rounds with three or even four candidates.

In the second round it’s a simple case of the candidate who polls the most votes wins.

Between rounds

In presidential elections there are two weeks between the rounds, in other elections it is usually one week. Polling day for all types of election in France is always a Sunday – the theory being that most people are not required to work and therefore have time to cast their vote.

Usually the defeated parties in the first round will call on their supporters to back a certain second-round candidate – if a far-right candidate has made it through to the second round, you may hear calls to faire un barrage or activate the Front républicain. This refers to parties across the political spectrum agreeing to put aside their differences and vote for each other in order to block the far-right. 

Why does France do this?

The two-round system is an unusual one – only a handful of countries use it and many of those that do are former French colonies who inherited the system from France. 

France voted to implement a two-round majority system for presidential elections in a 1962 referendum – the model was applied for the first time in 1965 when Charles de Gaulle was re-elected.

Prior to that the French president was generally chosen by the parliament and other elected officials – the exception to this was during the Second Republic when Napoleon II was directly chosen by the electorate (male members of the public at that time) during the 1848 presidential election with 74.2 percent of the vote.

The main argument in favour of it is that it allows the greatest number of people to select a candidate that they are happy with – even if your preferred candidate got knocked out in the first round, you can still express a preference for the second-round candidates.

In one-round first-past-the-post systems, such as those used in the UK and US, a party can win an election without winning an absolute majority of votes. Two-round systems are considered by some to be more democratic because the winner ultimately has to win the support of more than half of voters.

It has been claimed that two-round voting gives greater political stability – although current events are challenging that theory.

It’s often said that people vote with their heart in round one, but their head in round two – picking the practical choice from the second-round candidates.

READ ALSO How did France end up with the two-round system – and should it be changed?

SHOW COMMENTS